Falcao and Welbeck: what are Man Utd and Arsenal thinking?
The two biggest deals of deadline day have raised as many questions as they have answered
As the dust settled on another hectic transfer deadline day, the two main deals that stood out were Man United's capture of Radamel Falcao, and Arsenal's purchase of Danny Welbeck.
Many have welcomed the transfers but both deals raise serious questions about the focus, ambition and direction of the two clubs involved.
United have spent a record £150m on players this summer, but there is a whiff of panic hanging over Old Trafford amid questions about how the club can afford all the new faces.
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
Down at Arsenal the question is why Arsene Wenger's first team squad features only six recognised defenders (and two established centre-backs), while he now has nine forwards (plus Mesut Ozil and Santi Cazorla) on the books.
A fortune for Falcao:
The headline news on deadline day at Old Trafford was the arrival of Radamel Falcao, and although he is only in Manchester on loan he does not come cheap.
The Daily Express says the player only agreed to the move if United "matched his £10m a year tax free salary at Monaco" and the upshot is eyewatering. "To ensure he is on the same £184,000-a-week 'take home' wages in Britain, United have to pay him around £350,000," says the paper. "That works out at £18m a year on top of his £6m loan fee and the huge investment underlines United's desperation to return to European football's top table next season."
That has raised concerns among some fans who recall the decline of Leeds United, who spent big in a bid to crack Europe and paid the price when it failed.
But while the massive outlay on players this summer cannot become a regular occurrence, it will not push the club beyond their means thanks to new broadcast and commercial fees.
Where is the focus?
Of more concern to Daily Mail columnist Martin Samuel is United's overall transfer strategy. With Robin van Persie and Wayne Rooney up front, plus Juan Mata and another new arrival in Angel di Maria, he wonders why Falcao was brought in. "They did not need another marquee striker... United do not have room for all these recent acquisitions," he says.
He is also confused by Van Gaal's defensive additions. Luke Shaw, Daley Blind and Marcos Rojo (with a combined fee of around £50m) are all left-sided defenders who are likely to compete for one position, left wing-back, he notes. "Stupid money, silly salaries, and players piling up in the same position. It is fair to say if United have had a plan in this transfer window, it has come out of left field."
United's work does "appear frantic" says David Conn of The Guardian, particularly when compared to the "strategic reinforcing" by Chelsea and Man City, who were notably quiet on deadline day.
Abandoning Fergie's approach:
United's level of spending this summer would have been dismissed by former boss Alex Ferguson as "kamikaze", says Oliver Kay in The Times. "United have always prided themselves on developing their own young players... Even if Tom Cleverley and Danny Welbeck are hardly of the class of David Beckham or Paul Scholes, it feels as if something might have been lost in the rush to clear the decks to make way for a vanity signing or two."
United's loss Arsenal's gain?
The arrival of Welbeck at the Emirates left many Arsenal fans experiencing deja-vu. "There was a predictable exasperation and a feeling of being underwhelmed as Arsenal failed to find a desired target man and resorted to agreeing a deal to sign a second striker-cum-winger," says The Times.
With Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain, Theo Walcott, Joel Campbell, Lukas Podolski and Alexis Sanchez already on the books it is unclear what Welbeck offers that Arsenal do not already have. Although his presence does add another domestic player to the mix.
"The question for Arsenal, of course, is whether Welbeck represents what they really need. The lack of options at centre-back – where Per Mertesacker and Laurent Koscielny are the only senior options – seemed the most urgent priority and looks worryingly like a gamble that may yet backfire over the course of the season," says Jeremy Wilson of the Daily Telegraph.
Wenger's familair failings:
Arsenal's purchase of Welbeck shows that United have changed their approach, but it could also be significant for Arsenal.
"Signing an English player, nurtured and developed through the ranks at Manchester United is Wenger's way of tipping his 'chapeau' to the greatness of Ferguson," claims Adrian Durham in the Daily Mail. "It's an admission that Wenger knows that despite coming close, the Arsenal manager can never emerge from Fergie's enormous shadow."
And as the window shut "two large elephants remained in the room", says Amy Lawrence of The Guardian, noting the lack of a centre-back and defensive midfielder in the ranks. "They have spent more money than ever in one window but doubts persist over their ability to challenge for honours with a squad that retains obvious weak spots."
Sign up for Today's Best Articles in your inbox
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
-
Today's political cartoons - November 2, 2024
Cartoons Saturday's cartoons - anti-fascism, early voter turnout, and more
By The Week US Published
-
Geoff Capes obituary: shot-putter who became the World’s Strongest Man
In the Spotlight The 'mighty figure' was a two-time Commonwealth Champion and world-record holder
By The Week UK Published
-
Israel attacks Iran: a 'limited' retaliation
Talking Point Iran's humiliated leaders must decide how to respond to Netanyahu's measured strike
By The Week UK Published
-
The wit and wisdom of Sven-Göran Eriksson
In Depth The first foreign coach to manage England on football, life and death
By The Week Staff Published
-
The Premier League's spending cap: levelling the playing field?
Talking Point Top clubs oppose plans to link spending to income of lowest-earning club, but rule could prevent success gap from widening
By Harriet Marsden, The Week UK Published
-
Is a new English football regulator an own goal for the game?
Talking Point PM hails 'historic moment for football fans' but West Ham owner warns it could 'ruin' Premier League
By The Week UK Published
-
English football and the etiquette of leaving the stadium early
Talking Point The belief that 'true fans stay to the end' does not always apply
By The Week UK Published
-
2023-2024 Premier League predictions: champions, relegation and golden boot
feature A look at the top flight talking points and pundit picks for the new season
By Mike Starling Published
-
Man City: can ‘one of the best sides in history’ win the treble?
feature Guardiola’s Premier League champions have two more trophies in their sights
By The Week Staff Published
-
Premier League: Man City vs. Arsenal predictions
feature What the pundits say about tonight’s title race showdown at the Etihad
By Mike Starling Last updated
-
Antonio Conte leaves Tottenham after ‘extraordinary’ rant at players
feature After another year without a trophy, Spurs are now searching for a new manager
By The Week Staff Published