Opinion

Making sense of Trump, Putin, and the DNC email hack

If it has become Russian policy to try and influence the election of the next president of the United States, then we, as citizens, should at least be aware of that intervention

I don't believe in conspiracies until I find proof to support them. I find guilt-by-association arguments illogical and unfair, overused by politicians and pundits alike.

But the theory that Russia facilitated the leaking of tens of thousands of emails, some of them damning, from the Democratic National Committee, cannot be dismissed as trifling.

There is, in fact, real evidence that the DNC email system was hacked by a branch of the Russian military intelligence service. There is real evidence that the hacker who leaked the documents, known as "Guccifer," has ties to the Russian Federation.

Meanwhile, Donald Trump has not coherently explained how Europe should handle the Russian incursion into Ukraine, nor has he expressed a definitive view on whether Vladimir Putin has a claim to parts of that country. But Trump has certainly spoken admirably of Putin. "He's running his country and at least he's a leader, unlike what we have in this country," Trump said on MSNBC's Morning Joe back in December.

Trump's intention to gut NATO's charter — until NATO countries pay up, somehow — and to undermine the collective strength that serves as a deterrent to Russia is also now on the record.

Putin's nationalism is not always irrational. His view of recent history is comprehensible. His desire to restore luster to the Russian brand is excusable. But Putin's tactics, his cult of personality, his persecution of enemies, the murder of journalists and harassment of political dissidents, his racism, xenophobia, corruption — all that is execrable. His designs on the Baltic states inject fear into an already jittery Europe. He is not a force for stability. All of which means the next U.S. president has hard choices to make.

I don't believe that Trump is wittingly doing the bidding of the Russian Federation or its security and enmeshed governmental and corporate interests. There is no evidence that Trump is unduly influenced by Putin himself. (And the Trump campaign denies that is has anything to do with the hack.)

But it's fair to say the Kremlin believes it would be able to prosecute Putin's policies with vigor and ease with Trump as president. It's not an unwarranted stretch to believe that Putin has heard nothing from Trump's mouth or from his campaign that would give him pause.

That, in and of itself, shouldn't be a huge problem. Foreign leaders have interests, too. If they decide that one candidate is better for them than another, then it would stand to reason that they translate that preference into policy. Here's what logic says: Just because Putin thinks Trump would be a better president for him doesn't mean that Trump would actually go easy on Russia, or that Trump thinks the same about Putin.

But if it has become Russian policy to try and influence the election of the next president of the United States, then we, as citizens, should at least be aware of that intervention.

And now we are. Because Russia really does seem to be intervening on behalf of Donald Trump.

More From...

Picture of Marc AmbinderMarc Ambinder
Read All
The cyber debate goes public
Marc Ambinder
Marc Ambinder

The cyber debate goes public

How would America verify North Korea's denuclearization?
Trump shows the document he signed with Kim
Analysis

How would America verify North Korea's denuclearization?

The NSA knew about cellphone surveillance around the White House 6 years ago
The White House.
Analysis

The NSA knew about cellphone surveillance around the White House 6 years ago

The transformation of Kim Jong Un
President Trump and Kim Jong Un.
Analysis

The transformation of Kim Jong Un

Recommended

Biden announces relocation funding for native tribes impacted by climate change
Biden at Tribal Nations Summit
Higher ground

Biden announces relocation funding for native tribes impacted by climate change

IRS hands Trump's federal tax returns over to House committee
Donald Trump.
access granted

IRS hands Trump's federal tax returns over to House committee

ISIS confirms its leader was killed, does not provide details
A militant is seen holding the flag of ISIS in 2015.
Another One Gone

ISIS confirms its leader was killed, does not provide details

Court rejects plan by Dutch national park to control wolf population with paintballs
A European grey wolf seen in the Netherlands.
Not A Great Idea

Court rejects plan by Dutch national park to control wolf population with paintballs

Most Popular

World's 1st hydrogen-powered jet engine could mark turning point for aviation industry
A Rolls-Royce engine seen during an airshow.
Flying High

World's 1st hydrogen-powered jet engine could mark turning point for aviation industry

Sanctions apparently hurting Russia's economy, Ukraine war effort
Vladimir Putin
New Pain no gain

Sanctions apparently hurting Russia's economy, Ukraine war effort

China's Xi has few good options amid protests of 'zero COVID' policy
Anti-zero COVID protest in Beijing
China's COVID protests

China's Xi has few good options amid protests of 'zero COVID' policy