Opinion

The price of a broken health-care system

Forget ObamaCare vs. RyanCare. Let's talk about the real elephant in the room when it comes to American health care.

This is the editor's letter in the current issue of The Week magazine.

Our health-care system has a fundamental flaw: It's far too expensive. Americans spend $3.3 trillion a year on health care, which is 50 percent to 100 percent higher per capita than in other developed nations. For our money, we get some of the world's most sophisticated treatment of cancer, heart disease, and other serious illnesses. But overall, U.S. health care is relatively mediocre, producing shorter life expectancy, higher infant mortality, and worse health overall than the systems in such countries as the U.K., Switzerland, Canada, Australia, and Sweden. RyanCare won't fix a broken system; ObamaCare didn't, either. Both were conceived as patches on an absurdly complex Rube Goldberg machine assembled over 75 years of haphazard decisions. Studies have found that 34 percent of the immense cost of our system is simply wasted, with no benefit to patients.

Is health care a commodity like any other, which you can either afford or cannot? Or is it like education, electricity, or police and fire protection — basic necessities that government should ensure that everyone gets? We can't decide. Our system is a clunky, free-market/socialist hybrid that ties coverage to employment, age, and income, with tens of millions of people falling through the gaps. Meanwhile, doctors, hospitals, insurers, drug companies, medical device makers, and malpractice lawyers strive to make as much money as possible tending to the sick. The average hip replacement in the U.S. costs $40,364; in Spain, $7,731. In the U.S., an angiogram is $914; in Canada, it's $35. Lipitor costs $124 per month here, and $6 in New Zealand. This is the elephant in the room. To address it, and to make health care truly available to all, would require radical change. But too many people and companies have a vested interest in a health-care system that's the most expensive and inefficient in the civilized world. So that is what we’ll continue to have, no matter whose name precedes "care."

More From...

Picture of William FalkWilliam Falk
Read All
Facebook's amoral algorithms
Mark Zuckerberg.
Opinion

Facebook's amoral algorithms

Why Denmark beat COVID and the U.S. didn't
An ambulance.
Opinion

Why Denmark beat COVID and the U.S. didn't

The limits of power
Soldiers.
Opinion

The limits of power

How fiascos happen
President Biden.
Opinion

How fiascos happen

Recommended

Transplant surgeons report successfully testing a pig kidney on a human
Kidney transplant
adventures in xenotransplantation

Transplant surgeons report successfully testing a pig kidney on a human

Trump reportedly pressed to send U.S. troops into Mexico uninvited
Donald Trump, Mark Esper, Mark Milley.
Hasta la lucha

Trump reportedly pressed to send U.S. troops into Mexico uninvited

Biden tells Democrats he thinks deal could be reached on package of up to $1.9 trillion
Rep. Pramila Jayapal and other House progressives.
let's make a deal

Biden tells Democrats he thinks deal could be reached on package of up to $1.9 trillion

San Francisco's lone In-N-Out closed after refusing to follow city's vaccine requirement
An In-N-Out restaurant.
in double-double trouble

San Francisco's lone In-N-Out closed after refusing to follow city's vaccine requirement

Most Popular

Where outing the GOP lawmakers at Jan. 6 proved futile
Jan. 6 riot.
'his street cred went up'

Where outing the GOP lawmakers at Jan. 6 proved futile

Republicans see inflation as Democrats' downfall
Grocery store tomatoes.
inflation nation

Republicans see inflation as Democrats' downfall

Colin Powell at his worst — and most human
Colin Powell.
Picture of Damon LinkerDamon Linker

Colin Powell at his worst — and most human