Opinion

In praise of moderation

For democracy to work, parties need to meet in the middle

Beware the purists. To get anything done in this messy, contentious world, you have to accept that other people have different values and objectives than you do. The trick is to find some overlapping middle ground where you get part of what you want. In a divided democracy of 330 million people, compromise is essential; as Washington politicians once implicitly understood, half a loaf is better than none. But in recent years, our politics have become deeply polarized, as the bases of the Republican and Democratic parties have moved further right and left, respectively. Cutting deals has become a lost, or perhaps abandoned, art. That's why the government briefly shut down last weekend. It's why forging a compromise on immigration that can pass both houses of Congress — and get past presidential adviser Stephen Miller's veto — will be so difficult. Both parties' bases are demanding total victory, and calling congressional leaders who are willing to take half a loaf wimps and sellouts.

Most Americans, I believe, still fall somewhere within a few degrees of center on the political spectrum, and instinctively distrust extremists. But in an overwrought political climate defined by the shouting partisans on cable news, moderation and compromise have fallen into ill repute. That's a guarantee of gridlock and dysfunction. In a defense of moderation, conservative writer Peter Wehner has pointed out that a smart strategist can be driven by moral ideals even while charting a pragmatic course. "Moderation," he says, "takes into account what is needed at any given moment; it allows circumstances to determine action in the way that weather patterns dictate which route a ship will follow." Victories achieved without some buy-in from the opposition are often short-lived — and followed by intense backlashes that can wipe out nearly everything that was gained. On immigration, as on many issues, there is a reasonable middle ground — if the purists will let us get there.

More From...

Picture of William FalkWilliam Falk
Read All
Bill Russell's legacy
Bill Russell
Talking Points

Bill Russell's legacy

The great COVID disconnect
People in Times Square.
Opinion

The great COVID disconnect

The turning point
Trump.
Talking Points

The turning point

The soul of a machine
Ones and zeroes.
Talking Points

The soul of a machine

Recommended

What's in the Democrats' big climate, health care, and tax bill
Chuck Schumer
News You Can Use

What's in the Democrats' big climate, health care, and tax bill

Major Indiana employers slam new abortion law
Eli Lilly building
the almighty dollar

Major Indiana employers slam new abortion law

Senate expected to pass Democrat tax and climate bill
Chuck Schumer
finally!

Senate expected to pass Democrat tax and climate bill

Indiana governor signs abortion ban
Pro-life and pro-choice demonstrators
on the books

Indiana governor signs abortion ban

Most Popular

How the U.S. killed Al Qaeda's leader, and no one else, with a flying 'knife bomb'
unmanned aerial vehicle
Briefing

How the U.S. killed Al Qaeda's leader, and no one else, with a flying 'knife bomb'

Amazon to buy Roomba maker for $1.7 billion
Roomba
the panamazopticon expands

Amazon to buy Roomba maker for $1.7 billion

Kim Kardashian and Pete Davidson break up
Kim Kardashian and Pete Davidson
the saga ends

Kim Kardashian and Pete Davidson break up