Reframed: The Woman in the Window – a thoughtful and ‘tightly structured’ exhibition

The artistic convention of depicting a woman positioned by a window “dates back millennia”, said Hettie Judah in The Guardian. From the craftsmen of the ancient world to Vermeer to Cindy Sherman, artists have found the window a rich symbol. It can be philosophical – “a threshold between interior and exterior worlds”, confinement and freedom – or more earthy: it has often been used as a pictorial shorthand for prostitution.

This thoughtful and “tightly structured” exhibition explores the history of the tradition, as it has survived down the centuries. Taking in sculpture, paintings, prints, photographs and drawings, it mixes bona fide masterpieces with “intriguing oddities”, grouping works together in thematic clusters that probe subjects including identity, voyeurism, solitude and longing. You can see Rembrandt’s touching Girl at a Window (1645), from Dulwich Picture Gallery’s own collection, and a whole section by contemporary female artists: notably, there’s a 1975 photograph of Marina Abramovic, taken when the performance artist swapped roles with an Amsterdam sex worker.

It gets off to a scintillating start, said Waldemar Januszczak in The Sunday Times, with a section that explores the sexual connotations of the woman at the window, dating back to ancient times. There’s carved decorative ivory from around 900BC from Nimrud, in Mesopotamia, depicting the face of a “cultish goddess of love” framed by a window.

The Week

Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.

SUBSCRIBE & SAVE

Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

Sign up

Perhaps more startling is a Greek pot from about 360BC incorporating what, even by today’s standards, is a riotously bawdy image of a man climbing a ladder up to a woman waiting above, his erection sticking out of his pants “like an uncooked frankfurter”. A Walter Sickert painting of “a prostitute sitting in a window” is juxtaposed with an extraordinary 15th century French sculpture showing the “virgin martyr” St Avia being “locked up for her beliefs”.

Towards the end, however, the show starts “clumping its way down the overtrodden path of identity politics”. A “beautiful” Picasso aquatint of his lover Françoise Gilot, for instance, is not so much analysed as “blasted” by the curators’ “casual accusations” about the artist’s “abusive” relationship with Gilot. Somewhere down the line in this otherwise engaging exhibition, “scholarship has given way to clichés”.

I thought the show was “filled with revelations” from start to finish, said Laura Cumming in The Observer. It is packed full of standout pictures, from a Botticelli portrait of a “steely Renaissance redhead” with her “fingers suggestively clasping the window”, to the 17th century Dutch painter Gabriël Metsu’s vision of an African woman “seated behind a stone sill in red velvet and pearls”.

Nor does it limit itself to canonical Western art: one highlight is an Indian miniature depicting “two women appearing at a window like performers in a play, arms around each other, their smiles exquisitely expressive”.

One of the greatest works here is Degas’ “stupendous” Woman at a Window (1871), in which the titular figure sits “still as a heron” in the gloom of a Paris apartment, as the light “strikes out her face with its dazzle”. This is an “enthralling, imaginative and constantly surprising” exhibition, “superbly curated” and visually ravishing. It is the kind of show that will “make you look harder and think longer about both art and life”.

Dulwich Picture Gallery, London SE21 (dulwichpicturegallery.org.uk). Until 4 September