How does The Bear season three measure up?
Ayo Edebiri's character Sydney is 'somewhat sidelined' but her directorial debut is a high point

Season three of "The Bear" premiered to its highest numbers yet, pulling in more than 5.4 million worldwide views in the first four days of streaming.
Given the astonishing success of the first two seasons, and how the show is "churning out superstars quicker than plates on the pass", it's little wonder expectations are sky high, said Rebecca Nicholson in The Guardian.
The show follows troubled chef Carmy Berzatto (Jeremy Allen White) as he tries to transform his family's Chicago sandwich shop into a fine-dining restaurant following the death by suicide of his brother Mikey (Jon Bernthal). "When the show is flying, it really is wonderful television," said Nicholson, but season three is "not 'The Bear' at its best".
The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.

Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
While it still "elicits a deep fondness", the new series has a "circular" feel that keeps winding back to the idea that Carmy may be stuck in a hopeless loop, forever repeating his mistakes. "Dogged repetition is the enemy of convincing story telling. It needs to move." And his sous chef Sydney (the "excellent" Ayo Edebiri) is "somewhat sidelined" throughout the latest instalment. "What a waste."
The opening episode delves into Carmy's journey to becoming a chef, splicing together flashbacks from his previous kitchen roles into a virtually dialogue-free montage filled with "people making ravioli and tweezing edible flowers". It's "avant-garde stuff", said Nick Hilton in The Independent, that "comes dangerously close to being boring".
Showrunner Christopher Storer seems more interested in showing off his technical abilities than weaving together a "cohesive" series, said Richard Lawson in Vanity Fair. And "what passes for humour" is essentially just the characters shouting "fuck you" at each other: "an exhausting shtick repeated ad nauseum".
There is "room for hope", said John Nugent in Empire. The show's "conceptual boldness" and reluctance to stick to a linear narrative remains "its strongest card". There are some high points: perhaps the best episode of the season is Edebiri's directorial debut, "Napkins", in which we discover how line cook Tina (a "superb" Liza Colón-Zayas) came to work at the sandwich shop.
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
The "most profound" scenes come from the guest stars. Celebrated chefs Thomas Keller and Daniel Boulud are among the real culinary talents to make an appearance in season three, nurturing Carmy early in his career. Alongside the "many wonderful guest turns", there are a handful of "genuinely mic-drop cameos" (the casting of handyman Fak's long-lost brother is "inspired").
All in all, the show's signature blend of "peace and chaos framed in superb camerawork and terrific performances" ensures "The Bear" remains "one of the very best shows on television", said Benji Wilson in The Telegraph. Could season three have been better? "I know what Carmy would say."
The Bear is streaming on Disney+ now
Irenie Forshaw is a features writer at The Week, covering arts, culture and travel. She began her career in journalism at Leeds University, where she wrote for the student newspaper, The Gryphon, before working at The Guardian and The New Statesman Group. Irenie then became a senior writer at Elite Traveler, where she oversaw The Experts column.
-
Why ‘anti-Islam’ bikers are guarding Gaza aid sites
In The Spotlight Members of Infidels MC, who regard themselves as modern Crusaders, among private security guards at Gaza Humanitarian Foundation sites
-
China: Xi seeks to fill America’s void
Feature Trump’s tariffs are pushing nations eastward as Xi Jinping focuses on strengthening ties with global leaders
-
Rebrands: Bringing back the War Department
Feature Trump revives the Department of Defense’s former name
-
10 concert tours to see this fall
The Week Recommends Concert tour season isn't over. Check out these headliners.
-
Video games to curl up with this fall, including Ghost of Yotei and LEGO Party
The Week Recommends Several highly anticipated video games are coming this fall
-
10 upcoming albums to stream during spooky season
The Week Recommends As fall arrives, check out new albums from Taylor Swift, Jeff Tweedy, the Lemonheads and more
-
A Spinal Tap reunion, Thomas Pynchon by way of Paul Thomas Anderson and a harrowing Stephen King adaptation in September movies
the week recommends This month’s new releases include ‘Spinal Tap II,’ ‘One Battle After Another’ and ‘The Long Walk’
-
Don't fly by the seat of your pants. Do it the healthy way with these airborne tips.
The Week Recommends Yes to stretching. Even more yesses to hydration.
-
'The Office' spinoff, a 'Mare of Easttown' follow-up and the Guinness family royalty in September TV
the week recommends This month's new television releases include 'The Paper,' 'Task' and 'House of Guinness'
-
One great cookbook: 'Jam Bakes'
The Week Recommends A guide to pristine jam-making, plus the baked goods that love them
-
September's books tell of friendship in middle age, teachers versus fascists, and Covid psychosis
the week recommends September books include Angela Flournoy's 'The Wilderness,' Randi Weingarten's 'Why Fascists Fear Teachers' and Patricia Lockwood's 'Will There Ever Be Another You'