Monsters: why is the Menendez brothers Netflix hit so controversial?
Ryan Murphy’s latest true-crime series recounts infamous 1989 Beverly Hills murders, but some critics say his retelling takes too many liberties with the truth
"Death, sex, privilege, lies" – the 1989 murder of Kitty and Jose Menendez by their sons, Lyle and Erik, "has it all", said Ed Power in The Telegraph. "At least, it does if you are Ryan Murphy."
Following Murphy's similarly provocative Netflix series about serial killer Jeffrey Dahmer, the "American Horror Story" showrunner has turned his hand to another grisly crime, this time revisiting the story of Lyle and Erik Menendez. They are serving life sentences without parole for murdering their parents at their Beverly Hills home.
While the brothers claimed they carried out the crime in response to years of horrific sexual abuse at the hands of their father, prosecutors argued the double murder was motivated by an enormous inheritance.
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
'Immensely slick and breathtakingly crass'
"Flashy, exploitative and propulsive," "Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story" is "peak Murphy", said Power. Like Dahmer, the nine-part series "struggles against the temptation to glamorise its subjects" and is at once "immensely slick and breathtakingly crass".
Cooper Koch and Nicholas Alexander Chavez try their hardest to "bring depth" to the titular "cartoon villains of American true crime", but a "haze of vulgarity" lingers over the show. Murphy even has the Vanity Fair crime writer Dominick Dunne (Nathan Lane) speculate about whether the brothers' relationship was incestuous – the "perfect excuse to crowbar in a scene of them canoodling in the shower together".
Trying to figure out what tone the show is trying to strike is "headache-inducing", said Imogen West-Knights on Slate. One moment, it leans into "Tarantino-esque, aestheticized violence", the next it attempts a sensitive portrayal of the "devastating" impact of childhood sexual abuse. "It is a doomed enterprise."
The show's attempts to explore multiple points of view amounts to "endless back-and-forth rug-pulling", said Jesse Hassenger in The Guardian. It's meant to come across as "multifaceted" but instead becomes an "exhausting" flip-flopping between two "overplayed notes": the brothers as traumatised abuse victims, and the brothers as "possibly sociopathic connivers".
Writing from prison, Erik Menendez himself has criticised the "horrible and blatant lies rampant in the show" and called the portrayals of himself and his brother "vile and appalling".
'Moral questionableness be damned'
Of course, Murphy has been "doing the rounds justifying the show's existence", said West-Knights, "making copious noises about handling things sensitively". Doubling down, he told Variety that "Monsters" is "the best thing that has happened to the Menendez brothers in 30 years. They are now being talked about by millions of people all over the world." Indeed, the show scooped 12.3 million views in its first weekend of release and shot straight to the top of Netflix's streaming chart.
Sure, Murphy knows how to "serve up a compelling binge-watch" and the show "clips along", said Power, but ultimately it's "competently put-together hokum made in the worst possible taste".
"Tastelessness and moral questionableness be damned," said West-Knights. With Murphy's track record, "I guess we'll do this all again in two years' time".
Create an account with the same email registered to your subscription to unlock access.
Sign up for Today's Best Articles in your inbox
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
Irenie Forshaw is a features writer at The Week, covering arts, culture and travel. She began her career in journalism at Leeds University, where she wrote for the student newspaper, The Gryphon, before working at The Guardian and The New Statesman Group. Irenie then became a senior writer at Elite Traveler, where she oversaw The Experts column.
-
The next place you'll find Starlink tech isn't a war zone — it's your airplane seat
Under the Radar Several major airlines are offering free in-flight Wi-Fi through the technology
By Justin Klawans, The Week US Published
-
The fishy diplomacy causing tensions between Bangladesh and India
Under The Radar Exports of a 'sacred' fish were recently suspended during difficult relations for the two nations
By Chas Newkey-Burden, The Week UK Published
-
Today's political cartoons - October 6, 2024
Cartoons Sunday's cartoons - Sunday scaries, in-fighting, and more
By The Week US Published
-
Unleashed: Big Dog Boris Johnson fights back
Talking Point New memoir is packed with 'derring-do, jolly japes' and 'alluring alliteration'
By The Week UK Published
-
TV to watch in October, from 'Disclaimer' and 'The Franchise'
The Week Recommends An HBO comedy from the 'Veep' creator, a mystery from master filmmaker Alfonso Cuarón and a reboot of an '80s classic
By Anya Jaremko-Greenwold, The Week US Published
-
From 'Teenage Dream' to millennial nightmare – where did it go wrong for Katy Perry?
Talking Points Brutal reviews for new album represent a serious setback in the pop star's attempted return
By Chas Newkey-Burden, The Week UK Published
-
'Wuthering Heights' and the Robbie-Elordi casting row
Talking Point The casting of Barbie and Elvis is 'fundamentally, egregiously wrong' in Emerald Fennell's new film
By The Week UK Published
-
Turner Prize 2024: has the art world's infamous award lost its power?
Talking Point As the award returns for its 40th anniversary, critics call for a revamp of 'sorry embarrassment of a prize'
By Irenie Forshaw, The Week UK Published
-
Lee: Kate Winslet biopic lacks 'nuance that made Miller exceptional'
Talking Point Winslet fought to get the film made, but critics are divided on whether it lives up to expectations
By The Week UK Published
-
A Very Royal Scandal: more trouble for the royals?
Talking Points Amazon Prime's new Prince Andrew drama could be another headache for the royal family
By The Week UK Published
-
Trigger warnings on screen spark dissent
Talking Point Are they a measure of sensitivity or just unnecessary posturing?
By Anya Jaremko-Greenwold, The Week US Published