Five years since Taliban fighters entered Kabul as the Afghan government collapsed and U.S. troops scrambled to complete their withdrawal from the country, the Taliban continues to expose the “wishful thinking of Western political and military leaders who insisted the movement had changed,” said the think tank Lowy Institute. The West has a “willful blindness” toward the Afghan regime and is “quietly lowering the threshold of behavior it’s prepared to accept.”
The Taliban’s “increasingly draconian policies have made Afghanistan one of the world’s gravest human rights crises, particularly for women and girls,” said Human Rights Watch. And yet among United Nations member states, only Russia has announced it formally recognizes the Taliban regime. Plus, “international condemnation is not enough.”
“Tellingly,” the U.N. now refers to the “relevant authorities” in Kabul rather than the “de facto authorities,” in effect “narrowing the linguistic difference between the regime and a recognized government,” said Lowy. Warnings of the widespread repression under the Taliban are still “accurate.” What has changed is the “willingness of the world to act on them.”
What did the commentators say? The U.S., in particular, has a “moral responsibility to not simply look away,” said Mursal Rahim, who fled Afghanistan in 2021, at The New York Times. Since leaving Kabul, the U.S. has “increasingly disengaged from the country and its people,” closing the embassy, withdrawing diplomats and leaving “sharply reduced assistance” for Afghans coming to the U.S. The situation in Afghanistan no longer “commands America’s attention as it once did,” but to continue in this vein risks accepting that the “systematic erasure of Afghan women is no longer its concern.”
What next? It may be unpopular, but Afghanistan’s “future depends on greater international engagement” with whoever is in charge, said Tobias Ellwood, the former chair of the U.K.’s Defence Select Committee, at The Telegraph. But importantly, “engagement does not mean recognition.” The goal is to ensure that Afghanistan, with its population of 40 million people, is “stable, secure and prosperous enough.” But that will “not be achieved by shouting from afar. It begins by reengaging with those who govern Afghanistan today.”
|