If Britain had PR, Ukip would win 99 seats. Food for thought
Calls for proportional representation will come from all corners on 8 May. But there's a reason to ignore them

A free daily digest of the biggest news stories of the day - and the best features from our website
Thank you for signing up to TheWeek. You will receive a verification email shortly.
There was a problem. Please refresh the page and try again.
It is very likely – make that 100 per cent definite – that there will be calls from across the country for a new system of proportional representation once this election is over.
Lib Dems, Greens and Ukip voters will be asking why they have so few MPs considering their parties’ popular support. Others might be asking why the SNP has so many, considering its voter numbers.
But would PR really be a fairer solution? Martin Baxter of Electoral Calculus has been crunching the numbers for the Daily Telegraph to find out.
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.

Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
Using current predications of the expected vote share on 7 May, PR would deliver Ukip 99 seats, the Lib Dems 49, and the Greens 37 – many, many more than they can dare hope for under the current first-past-the-post system.
Labour would be down to 213, the Tories down to 201 and the SNP on 23 rather than the 50-plus currently predicted by pollsters.
Here comes the big BUT…
To reach the magic figure of 326 MPs needed for a Commons majority, no two parties’ MPs added together (excepting a highly unlikely ‘grand coalition’ of Labour and the Tories) would come anywhere near.
“Any coalition would have to be an unwieldy three, four, or even six- party affair,” says Baxter. “It would be a recipe for fractious and fractured government.”
Before we junk the current system due to a single “unfair” election result, Baxter urges us to consider this: the average vote share for the three major parties over the 29 general elections since the year 1900 has been 44 per cent for the Conservatives, 33 per cent for Labour, and 19 per cent for the Liberals.
Compare this with the amount of “governing time” the three parties have enjoyed (counting coalitions as ‘half-government’) over the same period: Conservatives 54 per cent, Labour 29 per cent and Liberals 12 per cent.
“Now those are not quite exact matches,” Baxter admits, “but it is not an appalling outcome that flies in the face of democracy… When the losers clamour for change after the May election, we should resist their calls to chase the illusion of perfectability.”
Whether this cuts any ice with the pro-PR brigade remains to be seen - there could be some very angry voters around on 8 May. For instance, according to opinion polls, Ukip currently enjoy a 12-14 per cent share of the nation vote. But under the first-past-the-post system, the Faragists are predicted to win only one or two seats. Not 99.
Continue reading for free
We hope you're enjoying The Week's refreshingly open-minded journalism.
Subscribed to The Week? Register your account with the same email as your subscription.
Sign up to our 10 Things You Need to Know Today newsletter
A free daily digest of the biggest news stories of the day - and the best features from our website
-
Today's political cartoons — September 30, 2023
Saturday's cartoons - Trump's poll numbers, the Hunter Biden investigation, and more
By The Week Staff Published
-
10 things you need to know today: September 30, 2023
Daily Briefing Government shutdown looms after failed House vote, California Sen. Dianne Feinstein dies at 90, and more
By Justin Klawans Published
-
All about Zealandia, the Earth’s potential 8th continent
The Explainer The secret continent went undiscovered for over 300 years
By Devika Rao Published
-
Why is the UK pushing Germany on fighter jets for Saudi Arabia?
Today's big question Berlin has opposed the sale of weapons to Riyadh on humanitarian grounds
By Arion McNicoll, The Week UK Published
-
Is it time the world re-evaluated the rules on migration?
Today's Big Question Home Secretary Suella Braverman questions whether 1951 UN Refugee Convention is 'fit for our modern age'
By The Week Staff Published
-
Rishi Sunak's tree code: what is the PM's election strategy?
Today's Big Question Conservative leader lining up major policy announcements in bid to rebrand as 'change' candidate
By Elliott Goat Published
-
Will Rishi Sunak's green wedge issue win over the public?
Today's Big Question The PM draws dividing line with Labour on net zero ahead of the next general election
By Sorcha Bradley Published
-
Industry backlash as Sunak set to water down green pledges
Speed Read Automotive and energy bosses look for clarity after PM backs away from UK net zero goal
By Arion McNicoll Published
-
October by-elections: what's at stake for Labour, Lib Dems and Tories
Parties will contest two former safe Tory seats on 19 October, putting pressure on Rishi Sunak
By Harriet Marsden Published
-
Jobs for the boys: does the UK need a minister for men?
Conservative MP calls for dedicated cabinet role to combat 'crisis' in men's mental health and education
By Harriet Marsden, The Week UK Published
-
Nigel Farage: was former UKIP leader cancelled by Coutts?
Talking Point Plight of outspoken politician throws light on question of whether banks are playing politics with their own customers
By The Week Staff Published