Lone Survivor – reviews of 'authentic' Afghan war movie
War porn or critique of the American military machine? Film about Navy Seals in Afghanistan triggers debate
What you need to know
Military action drama Lone Survivor, starring Mark Wahlberg, has prompted debate among critics over its portrait of Navy Seals in Afghanistan.
The film, based on a New York Times bestselling book about a real Navy Seal mission and directed by Peter Berg (Friday Night Lights), has been praised for its gripping and realistic action but also criticised by some as "war porn".
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
It tells the story of four Navy Seals on a covert mission in Afghanistan to neutralise a high-ranking Taliban operative. When they stumble upon a group of Afghan goatherds, their position is compromised, and the mission goes awry.
Also stars Taylor Kitsch, Emile Hirsch, Ben Foster and Eric Bana.
What the critics like
Neither an anti-war tract nor a jingoistic rallying cry, "the brutal but humane Lone Survivor registers as a howl of despair for so many young men and women lost in war", says Ashley Clark in Time Out. And few films can lay claim to such a sustained, technically impressive rendering of the consequences of combat on the human body.
Lone Survivor features quite possibly "the most authentic gunfight you'll see and the most affecting view of combat since Black Hawk Down", says James Dyer in Empire. This is a potent glimpse at the reality of modern warfare for the Call Of Duty generation, and it scores a hit with every shot.
It can function both war porn and "a critique of the American war machine", but one thing's certain, it's a film that will get people talking, says Emma Simmonds on ArtsDesk. The actors are great and keep things engaging, while the bone-crunching action is thrillingly, sometimes terrifyingly rendered.
What they don't like
America's culture wars have reached the hair-trigger state where any film purporting to show the realities of war - Zero Dark Thirty and Black Hawk Down as well as Lone Survivor - is accused of being "jingoistic snuff", says Tim Robey in the Daily Telegraph. While this film seeks to avoid accusations of racism by seeming almost cravenly grateful for "a few good brown people", it "botches this aspect of his story with galumphing sentimentality".
Sign up for Today's Best Articles in your inbox
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
-
Geoff Capes obituary: shot-putter who became the World’s Strongest Man
In the Spotlight The 'mighty figure' was a two-time Commonwealth Champion and world-record holder
By The Week UK Published
-
Israel attacks Iran: a 'limited' retaliation
Talking Point Iran's humiliated leaders must decide how to respond to Netanyahu's measured strike
By The Week UK Published
-
Crossword: November 2, 2024
The Week's daily crossword puzzle
By The Week Staff Published
-
The Count of Monte Cristo review: 'indecently spectacular' adaptation
The Week Recommends Dumas's classic 19th-century novel is once again given new life in this 'fast-moving' film
By The Week UK Published
-
Death of England: Closing Time review – 'bold, brash reflection on racism'
The Week Recommends The final part of this trilogy deftly explores rising political tensions across the country
By The Week UK Published
-
Sing Sing review: prison drama bursts with 'charm, energy and optimism'
The Week Recommends Colman Domingo plays a real-life prisoner in a performance likely to be an Oscars shoo-in
By The Week UK Published
-
Kaos review: comic retelling of Greek mythology starring Jeff Goldblum
The Week Recommends The new series captures audiences as it 'never takes itself too seriously'
By The Week UK Published
-
Blink Twice review: a 'stylish and savage' black comedy thriller
The Week Recommends Channing Tatum and Naomi Ackie stun in this film on the hedonistic rich directed by Zoë Kravitz
By The Week UK Published
-
Shifters review: 'beautiful' new romantic comedy offers 'bittersweet tenderness'
The Week Recommends The 'inventive, emotionally astute writing' leaves audiences gripped throughout
By The Week UK Published
-
How to do F1: British Grand Prix 2025
The Week Recommends One of the biggest events of the motorsports calendar is back and better than ever
By Rebekah Evans, The Week UK Published
-
Twisters review: 'warm-blooded' film explores dangerous weather
The Week Recommends The film, focusing on 'tornado wranglers', stars Daisy Edgar-Jones and Glen Powell
By The Week UK Published