Coastguard payments scrapped after court case backfires
MPs to meet coastguard volunteers to discuss end of hourly expenses
“If we want a strong, resilient Coastguard for the future, we must make sure that those who step forward are supported, not penalised,” said Lynsay Mackay of the GMB Union. And yet callout payments for the 3,500 highly trained volunteers who operate on Britain’s coasts have been controversially scrapped.
Coastguard rescue officers are fighting to get the payments restored, with the GMB’s help. But, in the meantime, many are thinking of leaving the service. And with temperatures soaring and tourists flocking to beaches, seaside communities fear for the strength of any emergency response.
Worker status
As volunteers, coastguard rescue officers work for free but there has been a long-standing agreement that they can claim expenses for callouts and training exercises. These amount to roughly £11 an hour, below the minimum wage. In January, a Court of Appeal judge upheld an employment tribunal ruling that they were “workers” and not “volunteers” – because the need for them to attend callouts and training constituted a contract. This would mean they are entitled to the minimum wage and other benefits.
The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
That might sound good – and it was a success for former coastguard officer, Martin Groom, and the GMB union, who brought the case to court. But, rather than respect the rescue officers’ worker status, the Maritime and Coastguard Agency announced that it would have to “change how the service operates” and scrap the hourly payments.
The MCA said “the volunteer model” is the “best option to protect the future of the service”, and allows rescue officers “flexibility to continue to serve alongside their primary employment”. The move has “upset many within seaside communities and the coastguard service”, said The Guardian.
Justifying sacrifice
“We do a very high pressure job and undertake advanced training but now we are not going to get paid,” an anonymous rescue officer told the BBC. “It is just not right. We do not do it for the money but the money allows us to do it.” It’s also easier to “justify the sacrifices” you make, such as getting a call in the middle of the night, or “halfway through a family barbecue”. At the very least, “it shows some appreciation”.
In Scotland, 53 MSPs have written to the UK government, calling on ministers to “intervene” to encourage the Maritime and Coastguard Agency “to pause its plans”, said The Scotsman. First Minister John Swinney has also committed to writing to the UK government on the issue. MPs from Cornwall and Norfolk have raised concerns too. Coastguard rescue officers, aided by the GMB union, are due to hold a meeting with supportive MPs in Westminster on 1 July.
Join 350,000+ subscribers and keep yourself informed with a selection of The Week’s most interesting, enlightening and entertaining stories - plus daily puzzles.
Will Barker joined The Week team as a staff writer in 2025, covering UK and global news and politics. He previously worked at the Financial Times and The Sun, contributing to the arts and world news desks, respectively. Before that, he achieved a gold-standard NCTJ Diploma at News Associates in Twickenham, with specialisms in media law and data journalism. While studying for his diploma, he also wrote for the South West Londoner, and channelled his passion for sport by reporting for The Cricket Paper. As an undergraduate of Merton College, University of Oxford, Will read English and French, and he also has an M.Phil in literary translation from Trinity College Dublin.