The ethics of Serial and true crime entertainment
Release of Adnan Syed has reignited debate over the role of the genre
The release from jail this week of Adnan Syed, whose murder conviction 23 years ago gained notoriety via the popular podcast Serial, has reignited the debate over the ethics of true crime entertainment.
Serial podcast: will Adnan Syed be cleared? The Week Unwrapped podcast: True crime, office homes and the electoral college
Serial “was the hit podcast that truly kickstarted true crime as an entertainment genre – and altered the course of justice as a direct result”, said Sky News.
There is “no doubt that the attention that ‘Serial’ brought to the case helped Mr. Syed”, agreed America magazine. But the podcast “seems to have little to do with the actual reason for his release”, given that his lawyers spent the last eight years since it first aired “trying unsuccessfully to get Syed a new trial”, it added.
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
Syed, now 41, spent 22 years in prison for the murder and kidnapping of his ex-girlfriend Hae Min Lee. But his conviction was quashed this week and he was released into home detention. A new trial has been ordered.
So is true crime entertainment a help to the criminal justice system and what are the ethics behind it?
‘A tendency to distort people’s views’
The attention that true crime brings to criminal cases can go some way to finding justice. Australian podcast The Teacher’s Pet prompted a number of clues from listeners who remembered information that was relevant to Sydney teacher Lyn Dawson’s disappearance in 1982.
But one of the issues with true crime series is they concentrate on a small part of the criminal justice system. “They tend to focus on the most exceptional parts of the system and therefore kind of the most spectacular, but because of that often the rarest kind of breakdowns,” John Pfaff, professor of law at Fordham University, told America.
More broadly, while these shows are educational in nature and bring “more attention to potential injustices”, they also have “a tendency to distort people’s views of crime and justice," Dawn Cecil, a criminology professor at the University of South Florida, told AFP.
On top of this, true crime “invites us to speculate, score points and take sides”, says Amelia Tate in The Guardian. It “invites us to be entitled” and attempts to force us to be certain about something rather that admitting “that we are just spectators; that we know very little at all”.
‘Conspicuously well made’
Much of the success of true crime entertainment in recent years is down to the fact that many high-profile series are “conspicuously well made, with lovely visuals and strong reporting”, said Vulture’s Alice Bolin. They have “subtle senses of theme and character, and they often feel professional, pensive, quiet – so far from vulgar or sensational”, she added.
But equally, “behind every gripping case, there is a family who have suffered and don’t want to pick over the horrific details, no matter how sensitively they’re treated”, said Hannah Verdier in The Guardian. The family of Hae Min Lee, who Syed was convicted of murdering, “has regularly said they are unable to move on because of all the attention on her case”, reported AFP.
“This is not a podcast for me. It’s real life,” Lee’s brother Young Lee said through tears in a statement to the court this week. “It’s a nightmare.”
Sign up for Today's Best Articles in your inbox
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
Jamie Timson is the UK news editor, curating The Week UK's daily morning newsletter and setting the agenda for the day's news output. He was first a member of the team from 2015 to 2019, progressing from intern to senior staff writer, and then rejoined in September 2022. As a founding panellist on “The Week Unwrapped” podcast, he has discussed politics, foreign affairs and conspiracy theories, sometimes separately, sometimes all at once. In between working at The Week, Jamie was a senior press officer at the Department for Transport, with a penchant for crisis communications, working on Brexit, the response to Covid-19 and HS2, among others.
-
Last hopes for justice for UK's nuclear test veterans
Under the Radar Thousands of ex-service personnel say their lives have been blighted by aggressive cancers and genetic mutations
By Sorcha Bradley, The Week UK Published
-
'It may not be surprising that creative work is used without permission'
Instant Opinion Opinion, comment and editorials of the day
By Justin Klawans, The Week US Published
-
5 simple items to help make your airplane seat more comfortable
The Week Recommends Gel cushions and inflatable travel pillows make a world of difference
By Catherine Garcia, The Week US Published
-
Menendez brothers may go free in LA prosecutor plan
Speed Read Prosecutors are asking for the brothers to be resentenced for the 1989 murder of their parents
By Peter Weber, The Week US Published
-
FBI: US violent crime falls again, hits pre-Covid levels
Speed Read A wide-ranging report found that violent crime dropped 3% in the last year, while murder dropped 11.6%
By Peter Weber, The Week US Published
-
Kenya's 'epidemic of violence' against female athletes
Under the Radar Murder of Olympic marathon runner Rebecca Cheptegei spotlights 'trend' of killings and wider culture of domestic abuse
By Harriet Marsden, The Week UK Published
-
Nevada politician guilty of murdering journalist
Speed Read Robert Telles was found guilty of murdering investigative journalist Jeff German in 2022
By Rafi Schwartz, The Week US Published
-
Why some Kenyans are sceptical about 'vampire' serial killer
Under the Radar 'Kenya's Ted Bundy' has been linked to dozens of murders, but sceptics have questioned whether he is a scapegoat for the murders of anti-government activists
By Chas Newkey-Burden, The Week UK Published
-
A bus stop tragedy and China's anti-Japanese rhetoric
Talking Point Suzhou attack described as the product of 'decades of hate education'
By The Week UK Published
-
Kyle Clifford: crossbow suspect caught near Enfield cemetery
Speed Read The 26-year-old is alleged to have killed the wife and two daughters of BBC racing commentator John Hunt
By Arion McNicoll, The Week UK Published
-
French schools and the scourge of teenage violence
Talking Point Gabriel Attal announces 'bold' intervention to tackle rise in violent incidents
By The Week UK Published