The rise of AI in the courtroom
Do advances in artificial intelligence mean technology could soon replace flesh-and-blood lawyers?
Fears about artificial intelligence putting people out of work have been around for decades, with vocations like manufacturing, bookkeeping and driving thought to be most at risk. But now, thanks to recent advances in the world of AI, lawyers might also be under threat.
DoNotPay, an app launched in 2015 that claims to be the world’s first robot lawyer, is trialling the use of AI in place of a barrister to defend someone in court next month. For the first time, a smartphone-run AI device will listen to all discussions in the courtroom before telling the defendant – who has been charged with speeding – how to respond via an earbud.
According to New Scientist’s tech reporter Matthew Sparkes, DoNotPay has agreed to pay any fines “should they be imposed” on behalf of the defendant, whose identity has not been revealed. The location of the court is also under wraps, but it was chosen because it classes the smartphone-earbud set-up as “a hearing aid”, therefore enabling the experiment to take place.
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
‘Aim to replace some lawyers’
The AI used by DoNotPay has been “trained to stick to factual statements, rather than saying whatever it could to win a case regardless of truth”, said Sparkes. The aim of the firm’s founder, Joshua Browder, is for the software to “eventually replace some lawyers”.
“It’s all about language, and that’s what lawyers charge hundreds or thousands of dollars an hour to do,” Browder is quoted as saying in the magazine. “There’ll still be a lot of good lawyers out there who may be arguing in the European Court of Human Rights, but a lot of lawyers are just charging way too much money to copy and paste documents and I think they will definitely be replaced, and they should be replaced.”
DoNotPay has raised $27.7m “from tech-focused venture capital firms”, reported CBS News, and over the years the app has used AI to help more than two million people resolve customer service disputes, challenge parking tickets and settle court cases, “among other issues”.
Browder’s “courtroom gambit” is the latest in a series of curveballs that advanced AI tools are “throwing at the legal professions”, said Politico’s Ben Schreckinger. Another example, from just last week, was the publication of a “non-peer-reviewed preprint paper” predicting that an AI would soon be able to pass the multiple-choice section of the US Multistate Bar Exam.
‘Better off hiring flesh-and-blood lawyers’
But despite these advances, defendants “would still be better off hiring flesh-and-blood lawyers”, US litigator Nicholas Saady told Schreckinger. Good litigation is about reading body language and making “split-second strategic decisions in the middle of courtroom exchanges” – and “it doesn’t seem like AI is ready to get on its feet in court”, he explained.
In an interview with CBS News, Browder highlighted the limitations of the technology. He pointed out that the AI-powered chatbot ChatGPT, which has made headlines in recent weeks for its stunningly convincing communication skills, is “very good at holding conversations, but it’s terrible at knowing the law.
“We’ve had to retrain these AIs to know the law,” he said. “AI is a high school student, and we’re sending it to law school.”
Create an account with the same email registered to your subscription to unlock access.
Sign up for Today's Best Articles in your inbox
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
Kate Samuelson is the newsletter editor, global. She is also a regular guest on award-winning podcast The Week Unwrapped, where she often brings stories with a women’s rights angle. Kate’s career as a journalist began on the MailOnline graduate training scheme, which involved stints as a reporter at the South West News Service’s office in Cambridge and the Liverpool Echo. She moved from MailOnline to Time magazine’s satellite office in London, where she covered current affairs and culture for both the print mag and website. Before joining The Week, Kate worked as the senior stories and content gathering specialist at the global women’s charity ActionAid UK, where she led the planning and delivery of all content gathering trips, from Bangladesh to Brazil. She is passionate about women’s rights and using her skills as a journalist to highlight underrepresented communities.
Alongside her staff roles, Kate has written for various magazines and newspapers including Stylist, Metro.co.uk, The Guardian and the i news site. She is also the founder and editor of Cheapskate London, an award-winning weekly newsletter that curates the best free events with the aim of making the capital more accessible.
-
'New arrivals are more than paying for themselves'
Instant Opinion Opinion, comment and editorials of the day
By Harold Maass, The Week US Published
-
6 stylish homes in Portland, Oregon
Feature Featuring a wall of windows in Collins View and a historic ballroom in Portland Heights
By The Week US Published
-
What's next for US interest rates?
The Explainer Stubborn inflation forestalls anticipated rate cuts
By Becca Stanek, The Week US Published
-
Should AI have rights?
Talking point Technology is becoming smarter
By Devika Rao, The Week US Published
-
Is the AI bubble deflating?
Today's Big Question Growing skepticism and high costs prompt reconsideration
By Joel Mathis, The Week US Published
-
AI is causing concern among the LGBTQ community
In the Spotlight One critic believes that AI will 'always fail LGBTQ people'
By Justin Klawans, The Week US Published
-
When even art is artificial
Opinion The AI threat to human creativity
By William Falk Published
-
The push for media literacy in education amid the rise of AI
In the Spotlight A pair of congresspeople have introduced an act to mandate media literacy in schools
By Justin Klawans, The Week US Published
-
The complex environmental toll of artificial intelligence
The explainer AI is very much mostly not green technology
By Devika Rao, The Week US Published
-
Artificial history
Opinion Google's AI tailored the past to fit modern mores, but only succeeded in erasing real historical crimes
By Theunis Bates Published
-
AI is recreating the voices of mass shooting victims
The Explainer The parents of these victims are using the AI to try and lobby Congress for gun control
By Justin Klawans, The Week US Published