Why ObamaCare's constitutionality is in question again


Republicans have found yet another way to challenge the Affordable Care Act in court.
Arguments begin Tuesday in an appeals court case brought by Republican states and the federal Justice Department seeking to declare ObamaCare unconstitutional. The newest challenge to the health care law comes after the 2017 GOP tax act erased a penalty for people who didn't buy health insurance, and Republicans say that invalidates the ACA as a whole, NBC News reports.
The case, which will appear before the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals in New Orleans, centers around the ACA's individual mandate. The mandate was declared constitutional in a 2012 Supreme Court case, which said Congress' power of taxation allowed it to impose taxes on those who didn't buy health insurance. But with the penalty slashed to zero under the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, a Republican coalition is now arguing that the lack of a tax means it's out of Congress' reach.
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.

Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
A group of GOP state attorneys general and governors first brought the suit to a Texas court last September, with Democratic attorneys general fighting back. A judge in that case sided with the Republicans and declared the ACA unconstitutional, though several analyses predicted the decision wouldn't affect health care coverage very much. The ACA's backers appealed the decision, and now, President Trump has dispatched Justice Department lawyers to add to the case against the health care act. Three judges, including one appointed by Trump, will hear the case.
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
Kathryn is a graduate of Syracuse University, with degrees in magazine journalism and information technology, along with hours to earn another degree after working at SU's independent paper The Daily Orange. She's currently recovering from a horse addiction while living in New York City, and likes to share her extremely dry sense of humor on Twitter.
-
RFK Jr.: How to destroy vaccination
Feature Robert F. Kennedy Jr. replaces all 17 members of the federal Advisory Committee on Immunization Practice
-
The god in the machine
Feature An AI model with superhuman intelligence could soon become reality. Should we be worried?
-
ICE: Targeting essential workers
Feature After a brief pause, the Trump administration resumes its mass deportation plan
-
Kennedy ousts entire CDC vaccine advisory panel
speed read Health Secretary RFK Jr. is a longtime anti-vaccine activist who has criticized the panel of experts
-
RFK Jr. scraps Covid shots for pregnant women, kids
Speed Read The Health Secretary announced a policy change without informing CDC officials
-
New FDA chiefs limit Covid-19 shots to elderly, sick
speed read The FDA set stricter approval standards for booster shots
-
US overdose deaths plunged 27% last year
speed read Drug overdose still 'remains the leading cause of death for Americans aged 18-44,' said the CDC
-
Trump seeks to cut drug prices via executive order
speed read The president's order tells pharmaceutical companies to lower prescription drug prices, but it will likely be thrown out by the courts
-
RFK Jr. visits Texas as 2nd child dies from measles
Speed Read An outbreak of the vaccine-preventable disease continues to grow following a decade of no recorded US measles deaths
-
Shingles vaccine cuts dementia risk, study finds
Speed Read Getting vaccinated appears to significantly reduce the chances of developing Alzheimer's and other forms of dementia
-
Measles outbreak spreads, as does RFK Jr.'s influence
Speed Read The outbreak centered in Texas has grown to at least three states and Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. is promoting unproven treatments