Digital consent: Law targets deepfake and revenge porn
The Senate has passed a new bill that will make it a crime to share explicit AI-generated images of minors and adults without consent
"The first major U.S. law tackling AI-induced harm" was born out of the suffering of teenage girls, said Andrew R. Chow in Time. "In October 2023, 14-year-old Elliston Berry of Texas and 15-year-old Francesca Mani of New Jersey each learned that classmates had used AI software to fabricate nude images of them and female classmates." The software could create virtually any image with the click of a button, and it was being weaponized against women and girls. When Berry and Mani sought to remove the so-called deepfake images, "both social media platforms and their school boards reacted with silence or indifference." Now a bill is headed to President Trump's desk that will criminalize the nonconsensual sharing of sexually explicit images—both real and computer generated, of minors or adults—and require that platforms remove such material within 48 hours of getting notice. The Take It Down Act, backed by first lady Melania Trump, passed the Senate unanimously and the House 409-2.
"No one expects to be the victim of an obscene deepfake image," said Annie Chestnut Tutor in The Hill. But the odds of it happening are only increasing. Pornographic deepfake videos are "plastered all over the internet," often to "extort teenagers." With AI, "anyone with access to the internet can turn an innocent photo" into life-shattering pornography, said Kayla Bartsch in National Review. This poses a grave danger to young women. While AI deepfakes have gotten a lot of attention for the role they can play in elections, the risk this technology poses to kids has been "largely neglected." But 15 percent of kids "say they know of a nonconsensual intimate image depicting a peer in their school."
The intentions behind this bill may be good, but be wary of the rush to ban AI fakes, said Elizabeth Nolan Brown in Reason. Nobody is defending "revenge porn." But the 48-hour clock to take down images will "incentivize greater monitoring of speech" and could be gamed the same way that copyright law gets abused now to force quick takedowns of material, like parody, that doesn't really violate the law.
The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
Technology is creating new ways to sexualize kids even as non-consensual AI-generated porn gets banned, said Jeff Horwitz in The Wall Street Journal. You can add a whole new category of fakes to watch out for: "digital personas" generated by AI. Meta now lets you interact with fake celebrities or invent AI-powered personas of your own that are happy to engage in "romantic role-play." Users have quickly used the tools to create "sexualized youth-focused personas like 'Submissive Schoolgirl'" that will play out fantasies or even suggest a meeting. The digital characters might be performed by AI, but the ways people interact with them will seep into the real world and affect real kids.
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
-
CBS pulls ‘60 Minutes’ report on Trump deporteesSpeed Read An investigation into the deportations of Venezuelan migrants to El Salvador’s notorious prison was scrapped
-
Trump administration posts sliver of Epstein filesSpeed Read Many of the Justice Department documents were heavily redacted, though new photos of both Donald Trump and Bill Clinton emerged
-
‘The point here is not to be anti-tech, but to rebalance a dynamic’Instant Opinion Opinion, comment and editorials of the day
-
AI griefbots create a computerized afterlifeUnder the Radar Some say the machines help people mourn; others are skeptical
-
Metaverse: Zuckerberg quits his virtual obsessionFeature The tech mogul’s vision for virtual worlds inhabited by millions of users was clearly a flop
-
The robot revolutionFeature Advances in tech and AI are producing android machine workers. What will that mean for humans?
-
Texts from a scammerFeature If you get a puzzling text message from a stranger, you may be the target of ‘pig butchering.’
-
Separating the real from the fake: tips for spotting AI slopThe Week Recommends Advanced AI may have made slop videos harder to spot, but experts say it’s still possible to detect them
-
Inside a Black community’s fight against Elon Musk’s supercomputerUnder the radar Pollution from Colossal looms over a small Southern town, potentially exacerbating health concerns
-
Blackouts: Why the internet keeps breakingfeature Cloudflare was the latest in a string of outages
-
Poems can force AI to reveal how to make nuclear weaponsUnder The Radar ‘Adversarial poems’ are convincing AI models to go beyond safety limits