Delhi's dogs earn Supreme Court reprieve

Istanbul has its cats, Cape Town its penguins and now, thanks to India's highest court, Delhi will keep its stray dogs. The country's top jurists have walked back a controversial plan to permanently round up the million or so ambient canines estimated to call Delhi home. The about-face comes after the court earlier this month ordered Delhi's one million estimated strays be captured, sterilized, immunized and placed in local shelters to combat the "menace of dog bites leading to rabies." But prompted by mass pushback both online and in the streets, the Indian Supreme Court revised its ruling last week: Rather than being condemned to mass detention, captured dogs not displaying signs of rabies or acting aggressively will instead be released back into the urban wild.

Causing 'panic among animal lovers'

The court's initial order giving authorities eight weeks to round up all of Delhi's dogs was "aimed to control rising cases of biting," The Associated Press said, including "incidents involving children." Delhi sees some 2,000 "dog bite episodes every day," according to "some estimates based on hospital records." Regardless of bite rates, the order caused a "panic among animal lovers and welfare organizations," many of which argued the city has "nowhere near the infrastructure to house its vast stray population," CNN said.

With millions of stray dogs nationwide, India "accounts for 36% of the total rabies-related deaths in the world," the BBC said, citing World Health Organization data. Despite that threat, critics of the court's ruling cited feasibility as their concern. "Most Indian cities currently do not have even 1% of the capacity" necessary to "rehabilitate stray dogs in shelters," said animal rights activist Nilesh Bhanage to the outlet. The order was an "impractical unscientific move" and a "shortsighted measure for a problem" in need of "long term solutions," said environmental journalist Bahar Dutt on X.

Subscribe to The Week

Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.

SUBSCRIBE & SAVE

Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

Sign up

A 'progressive step' that balances 'animal welfare and public safety'

In its revised ruling, the Indian Supreme Court "suspended the 'catch-and-keep' plan," The Guardian said, offering in its place a "more 'holistic' India-wide approach." The new order will see stray dogs "sterilized, vaccinated" and "dewormed" before they are ultimately "returned to the neighborhoods" where initially captured. The ruling also specified that "canines exhibiting aggressive behavior or infected with rabies shall not be released into public spaces," said Indian newspaper The Hindu. The order accordingly bans unregulated public feeding of stray dogs, but calls for the establishment of "designated areas for feeding" across the country, CNN said.

By scaling back their initial order, India's Supreme Court made a "progressive step toward balancing animal welfare and public safety," said Rahul Gandhi, the leader of the Indian parliamentary opposition, on X. The court made a "very good decision," Delhi Mayor Raja Iqbal Singh said. "We all love street dogs and we are all dog lovers."

Crucially, the court "has not clarified what 'an aggressive dog' is," Reuters said, citing an interview between the ANI news agency and former federal minister and animal rights activist Maneka Gandhi.