Is the 'Mean Girls' movie musical a glorious revisitation or the worst idea in forever?
Every critic feels some kinda way about the reboot
A cinematic cultural touchstone launched in the early 2000s. A Broadway musical that made the Plastics and everyone else, well, sing, in 2018. And now a movie version of that same musical. "Mean Girls" is either the gift that keeps giving or, at this point, it's the white elephant present that nobody wants.
Predictably, perhaps for such a beloved and also two-decades-old property, the response to the newest iteration has been all over the place. Embedded in those responses is a treatise on the capabilities of retreads and movie musicals themselves.
'It's flashy but lacks emotional weight'
20 years can do a lot — or little — to a movie's script. Much of the allure of the original "Mean Girls" film was its biting commentary and quotability. Well, as times and taste have changed, Tina Fey updated a number of the original script's jokes and plot points. For example, in the new "Mean Girls" movie musical, the queerness of Janis, played by Auliʻi Cravalho, is not the butt of jokes. "But also gone is the line, 'Oh my god, Karen, you can't just ask people why they're white,'" noted Kristy Puchko on Mashable. "This suggests that Fey's revision was less aimed at clearing away dated or problematic jokes and more about dulling the edges of anything that might risk being provocative." An edgeless "Mean Girls" is just "Harmlessly Unkind Girls." As Maureen Lee Lenker of Entertainment Weekly put it, "Part of the genius of the original Mean Girls was how it captured the downright viciousness of teenage girls, and some of that predatory bite has been muzzled here."
Much of the original's now-timeless humor had to stay, of course, but in the new movie those references are often played with a knowing wink-wink nudge-nudge. That relentless homage to the original, according to some critics, doesn't play well. "It's bizarre for a film remake to couch itself so heavily on that same familiarity, recycling jokes enough times that it comes across as cynical. It begs the question of why you wouldn't just watch the original again," wrote Leigh Monson for AV Club.
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
And, oh, the varied gripes people have about the right way to make a movie musical. "All the effervescence and fun have been drained out of the material in this labored reincarnation, a movie musical made by people who appear to have zero understanding of movie-musical vernacular," said The Hollywood Reporter's David Rooney. "The songs seldom spring organically from the story and more often feel so awkwardly shoehorned in that you come to dread them."
'A surprising alchemy occurs'
Others would beg to disagree, and instead celebrate the new film's deft handling of the movie-musical genre. "Not every movie — indeed, almost no movie — was meant to be turned into a musical," wrote Owen Gleiberman of Variety. "But the trend of doing so has become more common over the last two decades, and when you see a movie-to-musical transformation that really works, a surprising alchemy occurs," and, for Gleiberman, "Mean Girls" the movie musical very much works. Similarly, "not since Rob Marshall and "Chicago" has a feature film debut shown such a confident, innate understanding of the musical genre and how to make it cinematic for a modern audience," noted Lenker of Entertainment Weekly.
This, fans of the singing movie version of "Mean Girls," argue is the preternatural impact of putting music in the mouths of these iconic characters. Take queen Plastic Regina George, as played by Renee Rapp, in the new "Mean Girls": "From the moment her smirking lips appear in close-up, sultry-singing, 'My name is Regina George, and I am a massive deal,' she has us hooked," said Puchko of Mashable. So much so that, according to Gleiberman, "you may wonder for a moment how Rachel McAdams, in the original film, made the impact she did without that song."
Retreads are terrible; retreads are sublime when handled astutely. Movie musicals are terrible; movie musicals are sublime when handled astutely. No easy consensus to be found. The best assessment of the 2024 "Mean Girls" movie musical might be an Instagram story posted by the new film's Damian, Jaquel Spivey.
He compiled a screenshot of a news headline from Screen Rant, "Mean Girls Box Office Nearly Recoups Movie's Entire Budget in Opening Weekend," alongside Angela Bassett's "If God be for you, who can be against you?" moment from her 2019 acceptance speech at Black Girls Rock. The sweetest revenge of all is not the Burn Book, but those box office receipts.
Sign up for Today's Best Articles in your inbox
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
Scott Hocker is an award-winning freelance writer and editor at The Week Digital. He has written food, travel, culture and lifestyle stories for local, national and international publications for more than 20 years. Scott also has more than 15 years of experience creating, implementing and managing content initiatives while working across departments to grow companies. His most recent editorial post was as editor-in-chief of Liquor.com. Previously, he was the editor-in-chief of Tasting Table and a senior editor at San Francisco magazine.
-
Kelly Cates to present Match of the Day
Speed Read Sky Sports presenter to take over from Gary Lineker at start of next season
By Elizabeth Carr-Ellis, The Week UK Published
-
Eclipses 'on demand' mark a new era in solar physics
Under the radar The European Space Agency's Proba-3 mission gives scientists the ability to study one of the solar system's most compelling phenomena
By Rafi Schwartz, The Week US Published
-
Codeword: December 16, 2024
The Week's daily codeword puzzle
By The Week Staff Published
-
2024 and the rebirth of body horror
Talking Point In a year of female-focused 'scintillating gore', have horror films gone too far?
By Chas Newkey-Burden, The Week UK Published
-
Movies to watch in December, including 'Nosferatu' and 'Babygirl'
The Week Recommends A vampire classic reimagined, a Bob Dylan biopic, and an erotic thriller
By Anya Jaremko-Greenwold, The Week US Published
-
Is it OK to sing at the movies?
Today's Big Question 'Wicked' sing-alongs produce an audience backlash
By Joel Mathis, The Week US Published
-
'Wicked' and 'Gladiator II' ignite holiday box office
Speed Read The combination of the two movies revitalized a struggling box office
By Peter Weber, The Week US Published
-
These 7 touring theater productions are ready to carry you through the holidays and into the new year
The Week Recommends Your favorite movie-turned-musical might be coming to a city near you
By Scott Hocker, The Week US Published
-
Wicked fails to defy gravity
Talking Point Film version of hit stage musical weighed down by 'sense of self-importance'
By Tess Foley-Cox Published
-
Kimpton Everly Hotel: the perfect base to explore Hollywood
The Week Recommends Escape the bustle of LA at this laidback bolthole
By Caroline Dolby Published
-
Can AI tools be used to Hollywood's advantage?
Talking Points It makes some aspects of the industry faster and cheaper. It will also put many people in the entertainment world out of work
By Anya Jaremko-Greenwold, The Week US Published