"On paper, 'Only Murders in the Building' is everything that's wrong with contemporary TV comedy," said Rachel Aroesti in The Guardian. Forgoing "outright hilarity" for an "excessively starry" cast, "high-concept plotting", and "emotional sincerity", the show is a product of the streaming era.
"And yet – plot twist! – 'Only Murders in the Building' is screamingly funny. In fact, it's the funniest thing on TV at the moment".
The show follows a trio of true crime podcasters and neighbours – Charles (Steve Martin), Oliver (Martin Short) and Mabel (Selena Gomez) – who solve mysteries in their swanky New York apartment complex. Season four delves into the murder of Charles' stunt double, Sazz, who was shot through the window of his apartment at the end of season three.
The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
But before the group has a chance to get drawn into their latest investigation, "Hollywood calls". Paramount execs are "fast-tracking" a movie about the hit podcast, with real-life celebrities playing the trio: Eugene Levy is set to play Charles, Zach Galifianakis is Oliver and Eva Longoria has been cast as Selena Gomez's Mabel.
Stars playing themselves can be "hit and miss", said Ed Power in The Telegraph, but the new cast members are "a hoot" and the original trio "effortlessly reprise the screwball energy" of the preceding seasons. There "isn't nearly enough" of Meryl Streep, though, who returns to the show as Oliver's blossoming love interest.
Still, the "charm" of "Only Murders in the Building" goes way beyond its dazzling cast and "steady stream of one-liners". At the heart of the show is a "compelling whodunnit" filled with twists that lay the groundwork for a "killer season".
It's "ingeniously" plotted, agreed Ben Dowell in The Times, and the "chemistry" between the trio is still "high wattage". But when they return to New York to hunt for Sazz's killer, the formula starts to feel "all too familiar", and the show is "too in love with film culture to skewer that world properly".
Season four "isn't perfect", said Rachel Aroesti in The Guardian, but it's certainly close: "the show remains an extremely rare example of a comedy-drama that does both equally, and incredibly, well".
"Only Murders in the Building", season four is streaming on Disney+
-
Regal Scottish castle hotelsThe Week Recommends These rural retreats are perfect for a Traitors-inspired cosy winter break
-
Will the public buy Rachel Reeves’ tax rises?Today’s Big Question The Chancellor refused to rule out tax increases in her televised address, and is set to reverse pledges made in the election manifesto
-
Margaret Atwood’s ‘deliciously naughty’ memoirIn the Spotlight ‘Bean-spilling’ book by The Handmaid’s Tale author is ‘immensely readable’
-
7 mountain hotels perfect for a tranquil autumn or winter escapeThe Week Recommends Get (altitude) high and unwind
-
The 5 best political thriller series of the 21st centuryThe Week Recommends Viewers can binge on most anything, including espionage and the formation of parliamentary coalitions
-
The 8 best dark comedies of the 21st centuryThe Week Recommends From Santa Claus to suicide terrorism, these movies skewered big, taboo subjects
-
Everything you need to know about last-minute travelThe Week Recommends You can book an awesome trip with a moment’s notice
-
The 7 best police procedurals of all timeThe Week Recommends There’s more to cops and robbers than just nabbing the bad guy at the end of the show
-
8 of the best horror comedy films of all timeThe Week Recommends From parodies to ‘requels,’ these movies will make you laugh and scream at the same time
-
The 5 best TV shows about the mobThe Week Recommends From the show that launched TV’s golden age to a Batman spin-off, viewers can’t get enough of these magnificent mobsters
-
Dry skin, begone! 8 products to keep your skin supple while traveling.The Week Recommends Say goodbye to dry and hello to hydration
