Standing 'sentinel' on social media won't fix Ukraine

"There was an early day where [immersion on Twitter] was very, very pleasurable," author Patricia Lockwood mused in a New Yorker interview last month. Particularly when political engagement spiked during the Trump administration, she continued, "you felt that you had to be on there every day — like, 8 a.m., at your post — otherwise, you couldn't control what was going to happen that day. If you didn't know about it, then it would go on without you, beyond your control." The feeling you had, Lockwood suggested, was that of "standing sentinel," keeping an eye on the world, keeping it safe somehow, from your little digital watchtower.

In his newsletter, tech ethicist L.M. Sacasas explores that final phrase further:

Sacasas wrote just as Russia's invasion of Ukraine began, but his warning against grasping for control via information accumulation seems all the more important several weeks hence. Self-appointed sentinels are standing up all over, wanting very sincerely to help Ukraine, to do their bit. But the rightness of that sympathy doesn't make it any less powerless in the average social media user — and, meanwhile, another hazard is at hand: This is an information war.

Subscribe to The Week

Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.

SUBSCRIBE & SAVE

Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

Sign up

So is every modern war, in some sense, but a confluence of factors here — the scale of the Russian propaganda machine, the war's European theater and the attention that draws, the sheer prevalence of smartphones and social media access among the people involved — makes for an unprecedented situation. The Ukrainian government, too, is not above mythmaking, nor is Western social media a neutral power. This feels like a new level of informational chaos.

Standing sentinel is never safe, and, when your watchtower is Twitter (or Instagram, Facebook, Telegraph, whatever), it is rarely worthwhile. But whatever benefits your post may have in more ordinary times — if indeed there is such a thing anymore — they are less obtainable right now, and whatever the costs, they are greater. Control isn't coming. Even clarity is probably too much to expect.