Italy’s Supreme Court has ruled that nightlife noise can harm health and infringe on citizens’ right to peace and quiet in a landmark verdict that has widespread implications.
In the first ruling of its kind in Italy, the country’s Supreme Court ordered the city council of Brescia in Lombardy to pay a couple €50,000 (£43,000) for failing to safeguard them against noise from drunk revellers.
“The decision concludes a 10-year legal case in which the couple, who live in Carmine, a district of the northern Italian city popular for its bustling nightlife, pursued a right to ‘a quiet life’ and ‘rest’,” said The Guardian. Many other Italian towns are worried about similar pay-outs, especially in areas where nightlife has become “increasingly boisterous, particularly since the Covid pandemic”, the paper said.
The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
SUBSCRIBE & SAVE
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
Latest Videos From
The ruling has fuelled debate further afield too. The Daily Mail reported in October that Londoners were “fighting to save the city’s nightlife after becoming fed-up with the constant noise complaints threatening to close their local boozers”. Dozens of London pubs, clubs and music venues were served with noise complaints after two years of quiet during lockdowns.
‘Fighting to save the city’s nightlife’
People who live in capital cities should expect noise, said Samuel Kasumu, a Conservative contender for London mayor. “No offence, but it’s London,” the former Boris Johnson aide told the Evening Standard. “It’s the most cosmopolitan, most dynamic city in the world. So you know, deal with it.”
“Fury was first sparked” in summer 2022 when the “iconic” 200-year-old Compton Arms in north London was served with a licence review by Islington Council, “after four new neighbours who moved into the area during lockdown complained that revellers were too noisy”, the Mail said. Pub bosses claim the pandemic has resulted in more noise complaints, as people “got used to the ‘Covid quiet’”.
The Jago, a live music venue in Dalston, east London, received a noise abatement notice from Hackney Council last year. “Since the pandemic, many surrounding buildings [in Hackney] have been converted into residential properties,” the venue wrote on Instagram. “This has resulted in noise complaints, which put the future of our venue and others at risk.”
And one of Manchester’s most prominent music venues, the Night & Day Cafe, was forced to turn down the volume following a noise complaint from a neighbour, who bought a flat adjoining the 30-year-old venue in 2020.
‘Global public health menace’
Noise is an “often ignored environmental threat [that is] having an increasingly significant impact on city dwellers”, said the Financial Times. “Far from being a mere nuisance”, noise pollution is a “serious health and environmental issue”.
Aside from damaging hearing, long-term sleep disturbance can lead to heart disease, diabetes and poor mental health, Inger Andersen, executive director of the UN Environment Programme, said in the FT last year.
Nor is noise “an unavoidable part of urban life”, she argued. Safe noise levels, defined by the World Health Organization as 53 decibels, are being surpassed in cities around the world. Last year, the UN found London to be one of the noisiest cities in Europe, said Coco Khan in The Guardian, regularly exposing residents to average sound levels of 86 decibels.
“As cities become more crowded, their soundscapes become a global public health menace,” Andersen said.
The European Environment Agency estimated in 2014 that noise pollution leads to at least 10,000 premature deaths annually. In January, the House of Lords Science and Technology Committee launched an inquiry into the effects of light and noise on health.
People complaining about noise “seem to be the monied nimbys, the wealthy curtain-twitchers, or the plain old killjoys”, wrote Khan, but it is “undoubtedly a class issue”.
Noise particularly affects lower-income residents who are more likely to live in industralised areas, near motorways and airports, and away from green spaces, she said.
According to a US study published in 2017, poor neighbourhoods were nearly two decibels louder than affluent areas. It is “the poorest bearing the brunt”, Khan wrote.
