Is Amy Coney Barrett the Supreme Court's new swing justice?
Still conservative, but independent


Amy Coney Barrett ascended to the Supreme Court in 2020 on a wave of conservative enthusiasm. And sure enough, she was part of a court majority that overturned Roe v. Wade. But these days "she is beginning to separate herself from the pack in important ways," said Axios. Among the signs of Barrett's independence: Her positions on Donald Trump's court cases "were significantly less favorable" to the former president than other GOP appointees. (She still joined the majority that granted some legal immunity to Donald Trump in his Jan. 6 case, though.)
During the court's most recent term she wrote concurring opinions "questioning and honing the majority's methods" while occasionally joining liberal justices in "notable dissents" against the court's rulings involving Jan. 6 and the federal government's air pollution policies, said The New York Times. That's prompting a reevaluation of Barrett after just three full terms on the court. "Has Amy Coney Barrett gone rogue?" asked Newsweek. Not necessarily, said one legal observer. But she is demonstrating a degree of independence. "She is demonstrating that she isn't beholden to anyone."
What did the commentators say?
"Justice Barrett has found her voice — and has easily become the most interesting justice," legal analyst Stephen I. Vladeck said in The New York Times. Barrett's writings are often "principled, nuanced and fair-minded." And while Democrats and progressives might not agree with Barrett's principles "what cannot be doubted is that they are principles." More than most of her colleagues, Barrett consistently tries to stick to those principles "even when they lead her away from Republican political preferences."
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.

Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
"Justice Barrett may show streaks of independence, but when it counts, she's as conservative as they come," Kimberly Atkins Stohr said at The Boston Globe. When Barrett departs from her conservative colleagues "she does so carefully, narrowly" and in a fashion that often has little impact on the outcome of the case. For the most part, Barrett is delivering exactly what her conservative backers wanted when she was confirmed to the court. "Her resistance only comes when she's not a deciding vote."
What next?
If Barrett is moving toward the center of the court, the court as a whole has firmly moved right. "Chief Justice Roberts looked like he was emerging as a swing vote, toward the tail end of the Trump years," Mark Joseph Stern said at Slate. Roberts has always been a conservative, but for many years he was seen as an institutionalist who tried to fashion rulings to forestall a liberal backlash. His ruling on the recent Donald Trump immunity case suggests that era may be over. "I think the story of the term is: John Roberts becomes a MAGA justice," said Slate's Dahlia Lithwick.
Barrett, meanwhile, will have ample time to work her influence on the court. At the age of 52, she is "also the youngest justice" on the Supreme Court, said The Washington Post. What's clear: Her supposed independence will only go so far. Barrett is a conservative through and through. "If anyone thinks she will 'evolve' over to the left side of the court," said Georgetown Law's Irv Gornstein, "they are mistaken."
Sign up for Today's Best Articles in your inbox
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
Joel Mathis is a writer with 30 years of newspaper and online journalism experience. His work also regularly appears in National Geographic and The Kansas City Star. His awards include best online commentary at the Online News Association and (twice) at the City and Regional Magazine Association.
-
The state of Britain's Armed Forces
The Explainer Geopolitical unrest and the unreliability of the Trump administration have led to a frantic re-evaluation of the UK's military capabilities
By The Week UK
-
Anti-anxiety drug has a not-too-surprising effect on fish
Under the radar The fish act bolder and riskier
By Devika Rao, The Week US
-
Sudoku medium: April 21, 2025
The Week's daily medium sudoku puzzle
By The Week Staff
-
Supreme Court takes up Trump birthright appeal
Speed Read The New Jersey Attorney General said a constitutional right like birthright citizenship 'cannot be turned on or off at the whims of a single man'
By Rafi Schwartz, The Week US
-
How might Trump's tariffs affect the luxury goods market?
Today's Big Question Luxury clothes, cars and watches could take a hit in the coming months
By Justin Klawans, The Week US
-
'You shouldn't need a private company to fill out paperwork for you'
Instant Opinion Opinion, comment and editorials of the day
By Justin Klawans, The Week US
-
Supreme Court backs wrongly deported migrant
Speed Read The Trump administration must 'facilitate' the return of wrongfully deported migrant Kilmar Ábrego García from El Salvador, Supreme Court says
By Peter Weber, The Week US
-
Could Trump's tariff war be his undoing with the GOP?
TODAY'S BIG QUESTION The catastrophic effects of the president's 'Liberation Day' tariffs might create a serious wedge between him and the rest of the Republican party
By Rafi Schwartz, The Week US
-
Offseason elections spell danger for the GOP
Feature Democrats flip Wisconsin's Supreme Court Seat despite Musk's influence
By The Week US
-
Supreme Court gives Trump 2 deportation wins
Speed Read The court ruled that the Trump administration could continue to deport Venezuelan migrants
By Peter Weber, The Week US
-
Is Elon Musk's DOGE job coming to an end?
TODAY'S BIG QUESTION Plummeting popularity, a stinging electoral defeat and Tesla's shrinking market share could be pulling the tech billionaire out of Trump's presidential orbit
By Rafi Schwartz, The Week US