Scottish independence: the pros and cons
SNP expected to set out plans for Scottish citizenship were country to vote to leave the UK
The Scottish National Party has been criticised for using public money to fund a report on Scottish independence that is expected to set out citizenship and passport proposals if Scotland were to leave the UK.
First Minister Humza Yousaf and Jamie Hepburn, the minister for independence, will publish the fifth in a series of independence prospectus documents on Thursday. It’s thought the report will “define who will be a Scottish citizen after independence”, as well as the party’s proposals for “migrant rights, freedom of movement, and fairer fees to apply for citizenship”, The Times reported.
A question mark was cast over the party’s independence campaign following Nicola Sturgeon’s resignation as SNP leader and first minister in February. But Yousaf, her successor, quickly took up the mantle, appointing the SNP’s first independence minister within his first month as the country’s leader.
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
The UK Supreme Court has blocked Scotland from holding a second independence referendum without permission from Westminster, and Yousaf said last month that Scottish voters should treat the next general election as a “de facto referendum”, said the i news site.
Here are the arguments for and against Scotland going forward alone.
1. Pro: rejoin the European Union
In the 2016 Brexit referendum, 62% of Scottish voters called for the UK to remain in the European Union, compared to England’s 46.6% of Remain voters. “On this point, at least, it’s clear what Scots want,” said Time’s foreign affairs correspondent Ian Bremmer.
As an independent country, Scotland could make a bid to rejoin the EU as a member state once a separation agreement was settled with England. The country could then begin to negotiate its access agreement, looking to benefit from access to the EU single market, as well as the free movement of labour, goods, services and capital.
Yousaf believes that the campaign for independence has become “all the more relevant since Brexit”, said Politico, and that Scotland is “ready and waiting to join the EU” if it were to separate from the UK.
But “political support around the EU table” could pose a further challenge; Spain “has professed opposition to Scottish membership due to its possible implications for Catalonia”, a region with “a strong independence movement” that could look to follow suit.
2. Con: trading problems
“The rest of the UK is by far Scotland’s biggest trading partner,” said Economics Observatory, a relationship that could be put to the test if Scotland were to opt for independence. The UK accounted for 60% of Scottish exports (excluding oil and gas), compared to the EU’s 19% and global exports of 21% in 2019, according to Scottish government statistics.
This could become more complicated still if the country were to rejoin the EU, thereby “tearing Scotland out of the customs union and single market of the United Kingdom”, said The Spectator’s Fraser Nelson. Analysis indicates that EU membership “would not offset Scotland’s economic losses from increased border costs with the rest of the UK” should a hard trade border be imposed, said Economics Observatory.
A London School of Economics and Political Science report published in 2021 examining the financial impact of Brexit, trade and Scottish independence found that “the costs of independence to the Scottish economy are likely to be two to three times larger than the costs of Brexit”.
3. Pro: ‘protecting’ the NHS
Scotland has controlled the operation of its health service since the devolution settlement of 1999. However, funding and overarching policy decisions currently remain with Westminster.
Preventing NHS privatisation has been high on pro-independence campaigners’ agendas. SNP MP Dr Philippa Whitford “insisted” earlier this month that independence was “key to protecting” the health service in Scotland, said The National.
But the SNP’s track record on managing its health service might not convince voters. The British Medical Association warned in June that the party’s “mismanagement of Scotland’s NHS has left the country in dire need of thousands of GPs”, and criticised its “failure in NHS workforce planning”, said the Scottish Daily Express. The service has struggled to tackle record waiting lists and cancer care targets in recent years.
4. Con: debt and deficit dilemma
Economic policy and growth are “at the heart of debates about the effects of independence on Scotland’s public finances”, said the Institute of Fiscal Studies (IFS). While it remains in the union, Scotland’s budget deficit “is subsumed within the wider UK budget deficit”. But “under independence, that would change”.
Scotland’s underlying fiscal position bounced back better in 2021-22 than that of the UK as a whole, according to official statistics published in August and referenced by the IFS. Its estimated budget deficit fell by more than 10 percentage points to 12.3% of GDP, compared to the UK’s reduction of 8.4 percentage points.
The “two main reasons” behind “Scotland’s national deficit” year-on-year reduction were that extra public spending during the pandemic reduced, and oil and gas revenues increased, said the BBC’s Scotland political editor Glenn Campbell. But “the gap between what’s raised in Scotland and what’s spent in and on behalf of Scotland is still very high”.
The IFS’s latest projections suggest that without economic growth, “tax rises or spending cuts would likely need to be even larger” to manage the deficit in an independent Scotland.
5. Pro: power over policy
The Scottish government would have greater power over its defence, social security and foreign policies were it to become independent from the UK. It would also have increased control over constitutional matters, energy and environmental policies, and immigration.
In its “Building a New Scotland” reports, the SNP has laid out its vision for an independent Scotland. It includes creating its own constitution, introducing the Scottish pound, setting up an independent Scottish central bank and reform of employment law.
6. Con: position on world stage
At least in the short term, Scotland would lose its access to transnational organisations including the global trade division at the UN, the G7 and Nato, which is currently granted through its union with the rest of the UK. The country would need to apply for independent membership of these organisations.
And while rejoining the EU could help Scotland to establish ties with potential trading partners and forge its own political alliances, this too could come at a cost. In 2019, the UK’s net public sector contribution to the EU was estimated at £9.4 billion, according to government figures.
Without representation at these organisations, Scotland could lose its ability to have its voice heard on global issues including climate change and international peacekeeping.
Sign up for Today's Best Articles in your inbox
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
Julia O'Driscoll is the engagement editor. She covers UK and world news, as well as writing lifestyle and travel features. She regularly appears on “The Week Unwrapped” podcast, and hosted The Week's short-form documentary podcast, “The Overview”. Julia was previously the content and social media editor at sustainability consultancy Eco-Age, where she interviewed prominent voices in sustainable fashion and climate movements. She has a master's in liberal arts from Bristol University, and spent a year studying at Charles University in Prague.
-
'The double standards don't trouble the critics'
Instant Opinion Opinion, comment and editorials of the day
By Justin Klawans, The Week US Published
-
Today's political cartoons - November 22, 2024
Cartoons Friday's cartoons - frozen assets, blazing fires, and more
By The Week US Published
-
How much of a blow is ICC arrest warrant for Netanyahu?
Today's Big Question Action by Hague court damages Israel's narrative that Gaza conflict is a war between 'good and evil'
By Chas Newkey-Burden, The Week UK Published
-
John Prescott: was he Labour's last link to the working class?
Today's Big Quesiton 'A total one-off': tributes have poured in for the former deputy PM and trade unionist
By Harriet Marsden, The Week UK Published
-
Last hopes for justice for UK's nuclear test veterans
Under the Radar Thousands of ex-service personnel say their lives have been blighted by aggressive cancers and genetic mutations
By Sorcha Bradley, The Week UK Published
-
Will Donald Trump wreck the Brexit deal?
Today's Big Question President-elect's victory could help UK's reset with the EU, but a free-trade agreement with the US to dodge his threatened tariffs could hinder it
By Harriet Marsden, The Week UK Published
-
What is the next Tory leader up against?
Today's Big Question Kemi Badenoch or Robert Jenrick will have to unify warring factions and win back disillusioned voters – without alienating the centre ground
By Harriet Marsden, The Week UK Published
-
Alex Salmond: charismatic politician who nearly broke up the Union
In the Spotlight Remembering the former First Minister who 'normalised' the cause of Scottish independence
By The Week UK Published
-
What is Lammy hoping to achieve in China?
Today's Big Question Foreign secretary heads to Beijing as Labour seeks cooperation on global challenges and courts opportunities for trade and investment
By Harriet Marsden, The Week UK Published
-
Is Britain about to 'boil over'?
Today's Big Question A message shared across far-right groups listed more than 30 potential targets for violence in the UK today
By Sorcha Bradley, The Week UK Published
-
UK's Starmer slams 'far-right thuggery' at riots
Speed Read The anti-immigrant violence was spurred by false rumors that the suspect in the Southport knife attack was an immigrant
By Peter Weber, The Week US Published