Getting hammered: Fine wine auctions at Christie's
The rise of the foodie has led to a growth in the popularity of rare whiskies at auction, says Christie's Noah May
On 5 December 1766, James Christie conducted his first auction in London. But this year, as well as celebrating our 250th anniversary, we are marking 50 years since Christie's fine wine and spirits department was established. That first sale included ten lots of wine, cognac, madeira and port, but as Christie's gained a reputation in fine art, jewellery, books, furniture and so on, the category fell by the wayside somewhat.
In 1966, Michael Broadbent, a master of wine who had worked for wine merchants such as Laytons and Harveys of Bristol, approached Christie's and proposed a specialist department, convincing the owners there would be a good market for fine wines. He spent the rest of his career hunting down great collections, be they in old Scottish castles or plantation houses in the Deep South, and made extensive tasting notes – the oldest he has tasted is a 1645 canary sack. At 89, he is still a consultant for Christie's and his publication, The Great Vintage Wine Book, is the best resource for information on old wines.
For 40 of our 50 years, we were predominantly a fine wines department; it's only in the past ten years that the spirits category - whisky in particular - has really grown. It means we get a much more diverse group of collectors coming through the saleroom door; people who wouldn't necessarily engage with wine sales. Our client base has become much more global – Asia, South America, Scandinavia, as well as mainland Europe and the US – and so there are simply more people interested in spirits and they have the opportunity to bid. In the early days of these auctions, you either had to be in the King Street saleroom in St James's, London, or have a representative there on the phone. Now, you can watch online and bid in real time from anywhere in the world.
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
Also, people are much more interested in food and drink generally and spirits are more accessible than wines. The level of quality you find in a bottle of a distillery's youngest single malt, say The Glenlivet 12 Year Old at around £40, is exceptional compared to an equivalent wine. The other thing is that if you buy a bottle of spirits, you can be fairly sure - because of the high alcohol level - that what you buy will be as it was intended to be when it was bottled: a perfect encapsulation of a moment in time. For wine collectors, there is an understanding that a few of the bottles will have been affected by oxidation, others may not have aged well, but the one or two that absolutely sing make the exercise worthwhile.
The days when the majority of people buying bottles hid them away as a collection are gone. Although some of the bidders are investing and speculating, many these days want to enjoy an exceptional moment with what they've bought. And, thankfully, working closely with clientele who collect, I can attest to the fact they open bottles because I've been lucky enough to taste special wines and spirits with them.
Someone who collects paintings can sit and look at them, but you can't crack them open. Uncorking a bottle propels you into an exceptional moment, an extraordinarily intimate relationship with the person who fermented the grapes or distilled the spirit, as well as with all those over the year who tended the barrels or laid down the bottle. In addition, I think that as consumers explore the nuances of different live releases from distilleries and land upon their favourite brands, many of them go looking for unusual experiences and rarities that can't be found on the retail market.
As well as weird and wonderful bottles, at auction you can become part of a story that transcends a brand – the journey of ownership can be just as fascinating and it's our job to trace a collection's provenance. Today, there are fewer discoveries to be found than in those early days of fine wine auctions, but when you do find something rare, it is all the more exciting. We sold a collection of spirits from La Tour d'Argent restaurant in Paris in 2012 and I was lucky enough to go and inspect it. Some of it was hidden underneath a layer of mould and, as I brushed it away, I found port, madeira and cognac going back to 1780.
There have been some fascinating sales and individual lots, including 14,000 bottles from the cellar of the Parisian restaurant Maxim's, a carboy of pre-Prohibition whiskey and cognac that was served to George VI at a banquet in Versailles in 1938. Recently, we had a very unusual lot. The Glenlivet master distiller, Alan Winchester, offered up his own bottle – one of only 100 – of The Winchester Collection Vintage 1966 single malt for auction to raise money for the British Crafts Council. We don't usually work with brands, but auctioning something that was created at the exact same time Christie's was preparing for its first fine wines and spirits sale was a lovely experience. The quality of the whisky spoke for itself, but there was an added dimension of the opportunity to travel to Scotland and spend time with Alan and lay down a cask of new-make spirit to be bottled in another 50 years. The lot fetched US$31,850, the second-highest price for any bottle of whisky sold at Christie's in New York.
NOAH MAY joined Christie's in London in 2007 as a junior cataloguer and progressed to being a fine wines and spirits specialist. In 2014, he transferred to the same role in New York, moving to the US with his wife – their son was born there in the summer of 2016. Christie's holds regular fine wines and spirits auctions in salerooms around the world, notably New York, Hong Kong, Paris and London. Many can be attended virtually through Christie's Live; christies.com
Create an account with the same email registered to your subscription to unlock access.
Sign up for Today's Best Articles in your inbox
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
-
The myth of 'healthy' moderate drinking
Under The Radar The shaky logic that a daily tipple can lengthen your life has been a 'propaganda coup for the alcohol industry'
By Chas Newkey-Burden, The Week UK Published
-
Put down the glass, Napa and Sonoma. This is where you should drink wine in California.
In Depth Paso Robles is a gem among the oaks
By Catherine Garcia, The Week US Published
-
Jurassic Park: how dinosaurs put wine on your table
Under The Radar The disappearance of the 'lumbering beasts' allowed the grape to 'take over the world'
By Chas Newkey-Burden, The Week UK Published
-
Orange wines to try this summer
The Week Recommends These amber-hued wines pair perfectly with bold dishes
By Irenie Forshaw, The Week UK Published
-
Best English wines
The Week Recommends Celebrate a homegrown success story with our pick of the best still and sparkling wines
By Adrienne Wyper Published
-
Guide to Temecula Valley, California
The Week Recommends Temecula Valley offers a feast for the senses with dozens of wineries to visit and menus to explore
By Catherine Garcia, The Week US Published
-
Most US adults ‘have been visited by dead relative’
feature And other stories from the stranger side of life
By Chas Newkey-Burden Published
-
Ca’ del Bosco: a winery with traditional values and vivacious design
Under the Radar Italian brand is adding extra sparkle to the international wine scene
By Kaye O'Doherty Published