Opinion

How America creates terrorists

Enabling Saudi war crimes isn't just a moral atrocity. It also increases the risk of terrorist attacks.

Yemen is in hell. Over the past few weeks, Saudi Arabia has tightened its strangling blockade of the country, trying to starve out the Houthi rebels as part of a quasi-proxy war with Iran.

America is directly participating in this blockade. It would not happen without our sufferance, and we could stop it at any moment. It's precisely the kind of thing that fuels furious anti-American hatred and terrorism.

"This humanitarian catastrophe, this famine ... is being caused in part by actions of the United States of America," Sen. Chris Murphy (D-Conn.) said in an excellent speech on the floor of the U.S. Senate. The Saudi "coalition" uses American weapons, aimed using American-provided targeting data, delivered mostly on American jets, which are in turn fueled by American tanker planes. At every point we are enabling Saudi war crimes — and conversely, if we told them to stop, they would do so in an instant.

The Saudis are barely even pretending that what they're doing is attacking the Houthi military. The overt objective is collective punishment: to inflict enough disease, starvation, pain, and death on the Yemeni population that they give up. Back in 2015 the Saudis deliberately bombed the electricity grid, which supplied power to the water treatment plant for Sanaa, the country's capital. A month later, with fuel supplies blockaded, the plant ran out of diesel and shut down. A cholera outbreak, which is predicted to reach over one million infections by the end of the year, was the predictable — and probably intended — result.

And it's gotten worse. As Murphy says, the blockade has: "barred ships from delivering life-saving food, fuel, and medical supplies. A 25,000-metric-ton World Food Program ship is currently as we speak being denied access to the port. Hospitals and aid organizations inside Yemen are shutting down as we speak, because they do not have enough fuel to continue operating. Vaccines will run out inside the country within the month."

Last week, perhaps enabled by the Trump administration's signals of unflinching support, the Saudis tightened the blockade, completely shutting down all sea, air, and land transport routes into Yemen. On Tuesday, Saudis again bombed the Sanaa airport, shutting down U.N. humanitarian aid flights, which were the only ones using the facility.

Deliberately starving an entire country is a grave war crime, specifically a violation of Geneva Convention IV, which protects non-combatants and to which Saudi Arabia has agreed. It forbids the targeting of hospitals (which the Saudis have done), the blockading of food and relief supplies, and in general deliberate harm of civilians as an act of war.

There are about 28 million people in Yemen, and roughly half of them are under age 16. Suppose you were a young person growing up in, say, Buffalo. Not the most prosperous part of the region, but not a dystopian hellhole either. But then suppose Canada, using French-built planes and weapons, and logistically supported by the French military, swooped in and started bombing all the power plants, hospitals, airports, and water treatment facilities for the city. Suppose France-armed troops set up roadblocks on all the roads connecting to the city, and French-built Canadian ships refused to let any ships on Lake Erie dock there. Further suppose that Canada was doing this not because of any direct conflict with Buffalo itself, but as part of a proxy war with Mexico, which was supposedly backing some rebel groups in the city.

After disease and starvation set in, would it be very surprising if some percentage of Buffalo residents developed a furious, incandescent hatred of France? Or if they dedicated their entire lives to destroying the French state and making the French citizenry (who had incidentally barely paid any attention to the disaster) feel some of the pain and misery that they had felt while watching their homes destroyed, their city bombed to smithereens, their family members slowly starving or vomiting themselves to death?

In the unhinged period after 9/11, noting the possibility of domestic blowback for overseas atrocities was often cast as excusing terrorism, if not being in league with al Qaeda. In reality, it is simply noting cause and effect. It is a grotesque moral atrocity to enable Saudi war crimes, but it also increases the risk of terrorist attacks. By all means, the American state should take steps to protect the country from terrorism, but we must also avoid fueling the violence and political chaos in which terrorism thrives.

More From...

Picture of Ryan CooperRyan Cooper
Read All
The time to build a giant vaccine factory is now
Vaccines.
Talking Points

The time to build a giant vaccine factory is now

America has gravely undervalued booster shots
Vaccination.
Talking Points

America has gravely undervalued booster shots

The hidden danger of woo woo cranks
Dr. Oz.
Opinion

The hidden danger of woo woo cranks

The drone war's quiet decline
President Biden.
Opinion

The drone war's quiet decline

Recommended

A Catch-22 in Taiwan and Ukraine
Earth.
Picture of Noah MillmanNoah Millman

A Catch-22 in Taiwan and Ukraine

Germany imposes new restrictions on unvaccinated
Angela Merkel.
'a very, very difficult situation'

Germany imposes new restrictions on unvaccinated

Olympic committee: 2nd call with Peng Shuai 'reconfirmed' she 'appeared to be safe'
Shuai Peng
'difficult situation'

Olympic committee: 2nd call with Peng Shuai 'reconfirmed' she 'appeared to be safe'

10 things you need to know today: December 1, 2021
A vigil for Oxford High School shooting victims
Daily briefing

10 things you need to know today: December 1, 2021

Most Popular

Meghan Markle handed win in court battle with U.K. tabloid
Meghan Markle
meghan vs. tabloids

Meghan Markle handed win in court battle with U.K. tabloid

Late night hosts joke about Trump's secret COVID test
Donald Trump shares COVID with Joe Biden
Last Night on Late Night

Late night hosts joke about Trump's secret COVID test

Michigan prosecutor may charge Oxford shooter's parents, too
Oxford High School in Michigan
In loco parentis

Michigan prosecutor may charge Oxford shooter's parents, too