Opinion

Blaming evil

The massacre in El Paso was not the product of inexplicable forces

This is the editor's letter in the current issue of The Week magazine.

At a time when Americans agree about little, it's safe to say that mass shootings, and those who perpetrate them, are evil. "He's just an evil person," Mayor Dee Margo of El Paso said of the white nationalist who killed 22 people and wounded 26 more. "Unspeakable evil," agreed Sen. Ted Cruz. "We are outraged and sickened by this monstrous evil," intoned President Trump, in describing both the El Paso and Dayton mass shootings. But what, precisely, do people using this word mean? As Megan Garber points out this week at The Atlantic, blaming abstract "evil" serves to suggest that America's ongoing massacres are inexplicable and unpreventable. It absolves gun laws. It frees from blame the political leaders and cable TV hosts who have fueled white "replacement" fears and dehumanized the very "invaders" the El Paso gunman used his assault rifle to exterminate. "Evil, used as a talking point, both throws up its hands and washes them," Garber says.

The best definition of evil I've heard comes from Columbia University professor Andrew Delbanco, who has devoted much of his life to its study. Evil, he has concluded, springs from "the absence of imaginative sympathy for other human beings" — a choice not to care about their suffering. The potential for evil in all of us can be activated, Delbanco says, when people come to believe that inflicting pain and death on others serves a higher purpose, such as establishing ISIS' caliphate or preserving the white race's dominance. In El Paso, witnesses said, the gunman stalked his prey with cold fury, shooting two children, many grandparents, a couple who shielded their baby with their bodies, and several weeping people who pled with him, "Por favor. No." In his manifesto, the gunman said that only mass killings can repel "the Hispanic invasion of Texas" and "remove the threat of the Hispanic voting bloc." His acts were evil, but not inexplicable.

More From...

Picture of William FalkWilliam Falk
Read All
Bill Russell's legacy
Bill Russell
Talking Points

Bill Russell's legacy

The great COVID disconnect
People in Times Square.
Opinion

The great COVID disconnect

The turning point
Trump.
Talking Points

The turning point

The soul of a machine
Ones and zeroes.
Talking Points

The soul of a machine

Recommended

What Ukraine can and can't accomplish with Western artillery
HIMARS.
Briefing

What Ukraine can and can't accomplish with Western artillery

Russia hunting pro-Ukraine saboteurs after Crimea explosions
Russian military police in Crimea
Ghosting

Russia hunting pro-Ukraine saboteurs after Crimea explosions

Understanding the cartel violence in Baja California
Mexican soldiers
Briefing

Understanding the cartel violence in Baja California

Analysts: Ukrainian strikes in Crimea are part of Kherson counteroffensive
Aug. 16 ex;o
Stategery

Analysts: Ukrainian strikes in Crimea are part of Kherson counteroffensive

Most Popular

Elon Musk urges Grimes not to get 'elf ear surgery'
Elon Musk and Grimes
lend me your ears

Elon Musk urges Grimes not to get 'elf ear surgery'

Giuliani appearing before grand jury in GA election probe
Rudy Giuliani.
testimony time

Giuliani appearing before grand jury in GA election probe

Alaska primary: Murkowski, Palin advance in new Top 4 voting system
Sarah Palin, Donald Trump
2022 Primaries

Alaska primary: Murkowski, Palin advance in new Top 4 voting system