Opinion

Rebelling against sanity

Defying sound health advice on COVID-19 won't save the economy

This is the editor's letter in the current issue of The Week magazine.

Our country was born in rebellion against authority, so it's no surprise Americans have always had a strong libertarian streak. We bristle at being told what to do, especially by the ­government — even when it's demonstrably in the public interest. Millions of Americans angrily objected when health officials and the government began warning that cigarettes could kill them, and banned indoor smoking, and required motorists to wear — ugh — seat belts. Such bondage! Each of these impositions on personal freedom saved immeasurable suffering and many, many lives. Government can also overreach, of course; finding the right balance between individual liberty and the common good is a perpetual struggle. Now, in the midst of a catastrophic pandemic, it is masks, social distancing, and the closures of public places and businesses that have provoked cries of nanny-state tyranny from such diverse voices as a Dallas beauty salon owner and Elon Musk.

Infectious diseases, however, have a strong anti-libertarian bias. Without knowing it, a single infected person sheds billions of viruses and can spread illness and death to anyone standing near him or even sharing the same enclosed space. And if COVID-19 lands that free spirit in the hospital, the cost of a typical, 20-day hospitalization is $30,000 and up, which all of us pay through higher insurance premiums and taxes. The freedom to ignore the virus isn't free. Several countries have used strict closures, testing, contact tracing, and masking not only to flatten their curves — but also to crush them. Taiwan (population 24 million) has had just 440 cases and seven deaths. Densely populated Hong Kong has had just four deaths. The U.S. may be stumbling into the worst of all worlds: repeated waves of infection into 2021 and a devastated economy paralyzed by ongoing, legitimate fear. This is not a good time to act like a 5-year-old shouting: "You're not the boss of me!"

More From...

Picture of William FalkWilliam Falk
Read All
Broken glass
Protesters.
Talking Points

Broken glass

When the rivers run dry
A forest fire.
Talking Points

When the rivers run dry

The terror of losing
Liz Cheney.
Talking Points

The terror of losing

Bill Russell's legacy
Bill Russell
Talking Points

Bill Russell's legacy

Recommended

Russia announces illegal annexation of 4 Ukrainian territories
Vladimir Putin
overstepping boundaries

Russia announces illegal annexation of 4 Ukrainian territories

Mark Hamill named ambassador to Ukraine fundraising project
Mark Hamill
may the force be with them

Mark Hamill named ambassador to Ukraine fundraising project

What's happening with the Nord Stream pipelines?
A pipeline.
Briefing

What's happening with the Nord Stream pipelines?

Putin acknowledges 'mistakes' with draft
Russian President Vladimir Putin.
a rare admission

Putin acknowledges 'mistakes' with draft

Most Popular

Will Ukraine be Putin's downfall?
Vladimir Putin.
Opinion

Will Ukraine be Putin's downfall?

Returning the Crown Jewels
Queen Elizabeth.
Briefing

Returning the Crown Jewels

Hochul advances plan to require zero-emission cars by 2035
Kathy Hochul.
bestie in a tessie

Hochul advances plan to require zero-emission cars by 2035