How the Bible became conservative book bans' unintended target

The ongoing efforts in deep-red states like Florida and Texas to ban books deemed culturally or sexually inappropriate for their depictions of racial injustices and LGBTQ+ content have spawned a surprising form of retaliation. Parents and community members alarmed by what they see as right-wing censorship have begun targeting the Bible for removal from schools and libraries, arguing the book's graphic depictions of sex and violence make it just as subversive and inappropriate as the materials being banned under conservative and often overtly evangelical Christian auspices. In one Utah community, the Bible has been permanently pulled from elementary school shelves, while other states have been pressured to review whether the Bible violates any of their newly passed restrictions on educational materials. All told, access to the Bible has become an ironic and surprisingly effective tool in the growing fight over who controls what children read.

The Bible is too "vulgar or violent" for some schools

Casual observers might be hard-pressed to distinguish a recent article from the humor website McSweeney's titled "Smutty books have no place in our schools. It's time to ban the Bible" from a very real, if tongue firmly in cheek, petition submitted recently to Utah's Davis School District to remove the King James Version from classrooms. The request follows a 2022 state ban on allegedly explicit reading material pushed by the conservative "Utah Parents United" advocacy group — an effort that "left off one of the most sex-ridden books around," the anonymous petitioner wrote in their official complaint, the Bible. Citing "incest, onanism, bestiality, prostitution, genital mutilation, fellatio, dildos, rape and even infanticide" as evidence that the "the Bible, under Utah Code Ann. § 76-10-1227, has 'no serious values for minors' because it's pornographic by our new definition," the petitioners concluded that "this should be a slamdunk [sic]." It turns out, they were correct.

Ceding that the Bible contained "vulgarity or violence," a representative from Utah's Davis School District confirmed to the Salt Lake City Tribune in June that the book would be removed from elementary and middle school shelves. It remains available for upper school students. The Torah and Quran have reportedly not been challenged, although just days after the Bible's ban was announced, a similar petition was filed to restrict the Book of Mormon.

Subscribe to The Week

Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.

SUBSCRIBE & SAVE

Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

Sign up

Bible bans and reviews are part of a larger national trend

Aside from Utah's recent ban, the Bible has been pulled from school shelves for review, if not outright removal, in Florida, Missouri and Texas. While "not frequent," this "kind of challenge where there's criticism with the contents of the Bible, in response to an effort to remove other books from the library on the same grounds, is something we've seen in the past," Deborah Caldwell-Stone, the director of the American Library Association's Office for Intellectual Freedom, said. It's "a reaction to efforts to ban so many books" across the country, Jonathan Friedman, the director of the Free Expression and Education program for the free speech advocacy group PEN America, agreed.

While Utah's ban is still in effect, the efforts to review and restrict the Bible elsewhere have largely resulted in the material returning to library and classroom shelves after review by the respective supervisory agencies. Nevertheless, the broader point being made is that far-reaching efforts to restrict reading materials in the service of limiting educational inquiry at large will inevitably "sweep up ideas and materials that you actually agree with," Caldwell-Stone said.

What has the reaction been?

Conservatives have pushed back on the effort to ban the Bible, accusing it of "trying to minimize the real concerns of parents," according to Utah Parents United curriculum director Brooke Stephens. Utah Republican lawmaker Ken Ivory seemingly agreed, complaining that the "antics" ultimately "drain school resources." However, in a lengthy statement posted to his Facebook page, Ivory, the legislator who initially sponsored Utah's restrictive book criteria, ultimately accepted the Davis School District's decision, ceding that the King James translation of the Bible can be a "challenging read for elementary or middle school children on their own" and "is best taught, and best understood, in the home, and around the hearth, as a family."

Still, education officials who remove material like the Bible for "fear that it might contain an image that could violate state law" shocks Caldwell-Stone. "It speaks to the heart of mass censorship."