Is flexible working better for business?
Labour wants to end 'culture of presenteeism' and make hybrid working a 'default right' for UK employees
The Labour government's new bill on employment rights could make flexible working a "default" entitlement for employees.
Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds, who will present the bill next month, said he wanted to end a "culture of presenteeism" championed by previous Conservative governments and some major businesses. Reynolds said flexible working, including the ability to work from home where possible, has been shown to "contribute to productivity" and improve staff "resilience".
Conversely, Amazon, one of the world's largest employers, said this week that it would order all corporate staff to return to the office five days a week from January, bar extenuating circumstances. Having operated with a hybrid work system since the Covid pandemic, chief executive Andy Jassy said the experience had "strengthened our conviction about the benefits" of having staff in the office full-time.
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
What did the commentators say?
The UK has one of the highest rates of remote working in Europe, but flexible employment arrangements have become a divisive concept among businesses and employees.
Research from 2022 suggested that workers "felt more productive" when working from home, highlighting the "ability to concentrate without the usual office noise" and the "capacity to structure their day" as positive factors, said the i news site. The time- and money-saving aspect of the "elimination of the daily commute" was also a driver for greater job satisfaction for employees.
For businesses, meanwhile, working from home means being able to "hire workers from a broader geographical talent" and cut costs on office space.
But the overall figures on job satisfaction and productivity "are inconclusive", said The Times in a leader article, questioning whether employees "misuse time" when "shirking from home". A new "de facto four-day week" also hurts the British economy in other ways, the paper said, "depriving shops and transport systems of customers".
Amazon CEO Jassy said the primary motivations for corralling employees back into the office were to "strengthen our culture" and have "more effective" sessions of "collaborating, brainstorming, and inventing".
That decision goes "against the evidence" that mandatory office attendance won't improve work productivity and job satisfaction, said Cary Cooper, professor of organisational psychology and health at the University of Manchester, speaking to The Guardian.
Allowing "flexible work" gives greater "autonomy" to workers, he added, making it more likely that "they'll work better" and "you'll retain them". Companies who "micromanage" won't see "productivity gains" and won't "attract the next generation", Cooper said.
The "remote work revolution" is a "gift" primarily for "older and more senior workers", said Alice Thomson in The Times, but it can be a "disaster" for the young. Younger workers are unlikely to have suitable "home offices or garden sheds" to work in and are more likely to feel "lonely, depressed and demoralised" by a lack of interaction with co-workers. They are also the workers that will benefit most from "in-person feedback and mentoring". However, that also "involves senior executives turning up as well".
What next?
Even if the new employment rights bill includes protections for flexible working, employers must "reach a satisfactory middle ground themselves" when it comes to interpreting the legislation, said Thomson.
A "balanced approach" would prevent staff from feeling "detached" but also avoid a "show of presenteeism" without tangible benefits. Employers should focus on "establishing clear expectations" with workers, setting "realistic performance goals" and "giving recognition" to "elevate the well-being of all employees regardless of where they work", said Euronews.
Enshrining flexible working as a "default right" could be "incredibly challenging" to impose on companies "hell-bent on presenteeism", said Helen Coffey in The Independent. Until "greater flexibility for employees" is "secure", workers may "just have to roll with the punches".
Create an account with the same email registered to your subscription to unlock access.
Sign up for Today's Best Articles in your inbox
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
Richard Windsor is a freelance writer for The Week Digital. He began his journalism career writing about politics and sport while studying at the University of Southampton. He then worked across various football publications before specialising in cycling for almost nine years, covering major races including the Tour de France and interviewing some of the sport’s top riders. He led Cycling Weekly’s digital platforms as editor for seven of those years, helping to transform the publication into the UK’s largest cycling website. He now works as a freelance writer, editor and consultant.
-
Top cooking shows for foodies
The Week Recommends From Bake Off to Chef's Table, these mouth-watering TV shows will inspire you in the kitchen
By Irenie Forshaw, The Week UK Published
-
The four presidents who were assassinated in office
The Explainer The unlucky men who fell victim to successful plots against their lives
By David Faris Published
-
Canada's carbon tax in the crosshairs
Under the radar PM Justin Trudeau's flagship green policy has become increasingly unpopular as citizens grapple with high inflation and cost-of-living crisis
By Harriet Marsden, The Week UK Published
-
India's lengthening working week
Under The Radar Fourteen-hour work days, meetings during holidays, and no overtime are just part of the job in India's workplace culture
By Harriet Marsden, The Week UK Published
-
The pros and cons of labor unions
Pros and Cons Joining a labor union can have positives — and negatives
By Justin Klawans, The Week US Published
-
'Super Mario' to the rescue: can Draghi fix Europe's economy?
Today's Big Question Former central bank boss calls for more innovation and investment – but faces 'too many moving parts for a straightforward fix'
By Elliott Goat, The Week UK Published
-
Why are older workers staying on the job?
Today's Big Question And what does it mean for younger workers?
By Joel Mathis, The Week US Published
-
Can Starbucks' new CEO revive the company?
Today's Big Question Brian Niccol has been the CEO of Chipotle since 2018 but is now moving to the coffee chain
By Justin Klawans, The Week US Published
-
Is the Fed ready to start cutting interest rates?
Today's Big Question Recession fears and a presidential election affect the calculation
By Joel Mathis, The Week US Published
-
Why are global stock markets plunging?
Today's Big Question Europe, Asia and Wall Street have all suffered big falls after US economy data spooked investors
By Rebekah Evans, The Week UK Published
-
Will Keir Starmer scrap the two-child benefit cap?
Today's Big Question PM signals 'change in tone' as Labour rebels prepare to back amendment calling for immediate end to controversial 'social cleansing' policy
By The Week UK Published