The UK equality watchdog has issued controversial new guidance for employers that says menopause symptoms can be considered a disability.
Symptoms of the menopause, which can include hot flushes, exhaustion, depression and brain fog, can be considered a disability under the Equality Act 2010 if they have a "long-term and substantial impact" on someone's ability to carry out their usual day-to-day tasks, according to the Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC). Employers could face legal action if they do not make "reasonable adjustments", which might include cooler rooms, breaks and flexible uniform policies.
While some women have hailed the guidance as an inclusive step, others claim it risks pathologising a natural process and could backfire by stigmatising middle-aged women.
The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
SUBSCRIBE & SAVE
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
Latest Videos From
'Yet another reason to write off' menopausal women
"We campaigned really hard for what's a perfectly natural life stage not to be considered a disability," said Mariella Frostrup, who co-founded campaign group Menopause Mandate with Davina McCall and Penny Lancaster. This feels "like a step backwards".
Like many aspects of female health, from pregnancy to endometriosis, menopause is "stigmatised, under-researched and its symptoms undertreated", thanks to sexism and ageism, said The Observer. But this guidance risks legitimising those harmful stereotypes and misses the real problem.
About three-quarters of menopausal women experience some symptoms. The "majority of cases" can be treated "relatively easily and cheaply" through hormone replacement therapy (HRT), said the paper.
However, only 14% of menopausal women are taking HRT. Many GPs are "reluctant" to prescribe it, thanks to the "misreporting of scare stories about the risks". Women also struggle to access HRT because of "acute shortages". And too few doctors have sufficient menopause knowledge; four in 10 medical schools do not include it in their mandatory curriculum.
Women are being denied the treatment they need, which would make many of the suggested workplace accommodations "moot", Dr Louise Newsom, GP and a member of the government menopause taskforce, told The Telegraph.
Talking about the struggles of menopause is "always a good thing in breaking the taboo", she said, but ultimately, "this is a healthcare issue more than an employment issue".
Anna van Praagh at the London Evening Standard read the guidance with "horror". It makes the prospect of hiring someone my age "about as attractive as walking headfirst into a lorry", she said.
'Absolutely no shame in this'
Critics have "misread what the EHRC actually says", said Kathleen Stock in The Times. The Commission is not arguing that menopause counts as a disability, but rather that debilitating symptoms might count as such. And in the case of symptoms like perimenopausal "flooding" – extremely heavy periods, sometimes lasting weeks and causing great pain or anaemia – who could deny this?
Perhaps campaigners who "reject disability terminology" could accept that ageing means you're more susceptible to "disruptive medical problems", and there is "absolutely no shame in this".
Don't forget that one in 10 women say they have left a job because of the menopause, Eleanor Mills, founder of online platform Noom and former editor of The Sunday Times magazine, told The Telegraph.
About 25% of women "really suffer at this point in their lives". Ultimately, "we need to keep as many women in the workforce as possible".
Women are made to "jump through hoops of fire" to get the support they need, broadcaster Narinder Kaur told MailOnline. Menopause isn't a disability, but "it is debilitating". Although the new guidance will not remove the stigma, "it's high time it's recognised", because the symptoms can be "brutal".
