The pros and cons of safe injection sites for opioids

The sites have saved lives but many worry they're too lax

Protestors in Philadelphia
Protestors in support of safe injection sites in Philadelphia
(Image credit: Cory Clark / NurPhoto via Getty Images)

The United States’ opioid problem has steadily been getting worse. In 2022, more than 110,000 people died of drug overdoses, "two-thirds of whom succumbed to synthetic opioids such as fentanyl," reported The Washington Post. One controversial solution are safe injection sites, described by Scientific American as "places where people who use injectable, but illegal, opioids such as heroin, can do so without fear of overdose, prosecution or spreading disease."

Some facilities have already been established in cities like New York City and San Francisco, while others have banned them. Global research has found benefits to these facilities, but many are still wary about their implications.

Pro: Acts as harm reduction

Harm reduction involves "meet[ing] people where they are ― on their own terms, and may serve as a pathway to additional health and social services, including additional prevention, treatment, and recovery services," per the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA). Creating safe injection sites prevents needle sharing and public drug usage. 

Subscribe to The Week

Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.

SUBSCRIBE & SAVE
https://cdn.mos.cms.futurecdn.net/flexiimages/jacafc5zvs1692883516.jpg

Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

Sign up

"People will not stop using drugs just because they are told not to, so the best way to manage the various side effects of drug abuse," wrote City Journal. "In addition to preventing death or disease, harm-reduction programs create an opportunity … to conduct outreach."

Con: Normalizes drug use

Having safe injection sites makes opioid use more commonplace. "Outreach efforts on the streets have enabled drug users rather than steer them toward treatment," Philadelphia council member Quetcy Lozada told the Post. "We have made [drug users] comfortable living in [their] conditions. A facility would only make that more accessible."

"The nation appears caught between the failures of the old war on drugs and a new harm-reduction approach that … appears hobbled by an activist philosophy at odds with the everyday realities of drug use in America," wrote Tablet Magazine. Safe injection sites don’t provide incentives to quit drugs, but simply make using them safer. 

Research has shown that safe injection sites meant "users were less likely to overdose, visit emergency rooms or commit crime," the Post reported. These sites create a "zone of stability" keeping people from "injecting in public in unsafe ways," Sarah Evans, the division director of drug policy at the Open Society Foundations, told GBH.

"There isn't a correlation between the opening of these sites and the negative things that people anticipate," Evans added. A 2014 study of safe injection sites found they didn’t "increase drug injecting, drug trafficking or crime in the surrounding environments."

Con: Could keep people from seeking help 

Drug access could keep people locked into addiction, making them reluctant to seek help. "As [users] drift to other parts of their lives and stay dependent on these bad drugs, we’re going to lose that life as a productive citizen," Michael Driscoll, a Philadelphia City Council member, told The New York Times

"We need to prioritize sobriety, not just allow addiction to continue and spiral," Pennsylvania state Sen. Christine Tartaglione (D) told the Post. Many drug users may also suffer from concurrent disorders such as depression or anxiety. "Only addiction treatment programs use an integrated treatment approach that addresses drug abuse at the same time as a co-occurring mental illness," wrote addiction recovery center Footprints to Recovery.

Pro: Prevents overdose deaths

Because safe injection sites are monitored, the facilities have prevented thousands of overdose deaths across the country, per the Times. Staff are often able to administer naloxone and oxygen to prevent deaths. Research on safe injection sites found that they lead to lower drug mortality rates and lower public drug usage. "People can’t recover if they’re dead," Jeremy Drucker, Minnesota’s director of addiction and recovery, told the Times.

Many people also "respond to the nonjudgmental, caring atmosphere of safe consumption sites by seeking treatment and other social services," wrote the Cato Institute. "Overdose prevention sites can be part of a comprehensive strategy that can save lives and address open-air drug use," said San Francisco Mayor London Breed.

Con: Causes problems with federal drug controls

The operation of safe injection sites is at odds with federal drug regulations. While the Biden administration has endorsed harm reduction strategies to combat the opioid crisis, the sites "operate in a legal gray area," per the Times. This is because of a 1986 statute making it illegal "to maintain or open any place for the purpose of using any controlled substance," per think tank R Street.

Safe injection sites remain illegal under federal law, so those that were opened anyway are relying on authorities not to intervene. Because of this, access to sites varies greatly depending on their location. "Even liberal elected officials and communities, like those in Philadelphia, continue to question what they consider more lenient approaches to opioid use," the Times added.

To continue reading this article...
Continue reading this article and get limited website access each month.
Get unlimited website access, exclusive newsletters plus much more.
Cancel or pause at any time.
Already a subscriber to The Week?
Not sure which email you used for your subscription? Contact us