“James Cameron’s semi-amphibious sci-fi franchise is back,” said Robbie Collin in The Telegraph. Small wonder: the combined box-office takings of the first two films now exceeds £3.7 billion.
‘Cheesily colour-coordinated’
Yet this third chapter is “even longer”, “more humourless” and “cheesily colour-coordinated than the last”, adding “astonishingly little” to the cinematic universe he has established with previous instalments.
Set, once again, on the planet Pandora, and once again filmed in 3D, “Fire and Ash” sees Sam Worthington’s US marine and Zoe Saldaña’s Na’vi people “do battle with a rival volcano-dwelling tribe”, who have allied themselves with Pandora’s human invaders. Yet its only sources of inspiration “appear to have been Avatar one and two”: you see the same pterodactyl race, the same bioluminescent seascapes. It’s like watching £300 million of glitter tipped “into a fish tank”.
The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
‘Photo-real’ spectacle
There are certainly some moments of déjà vu, said Ben Travis in Empire. But the storytelling is impressively ambitious: the new film builds on “the familial threads, the vast world-building, the interpersonal beefs” of the previous pictures.
And in terms of pure spectacle, it’s fabulous. “It’s near-unfathomable that barely anything on screen actually exists”; it’s “so photo-real, you never even think about it”.
Yet this “Avatar” feels “a zillion light years from the excitement” of the 2009 original, said Nicholas Barber on BBC Culture. The extraterrestrial setting has “lost its novelty value” and “doesn’t seem as dazzling as it once did”. If the franchise once seemed “exhilaratingly futuristic”, it now looks like “a relic of an earlier era”. “It’s terrifying to think that Cameron still has two more sequels scheduled. How much longer and more self-indulgent can they possibly get?”
-
The Zorg: meticulously researched book is likely to ‘become a classic’The Week Recommends Siddharth Kara’s harrowing account of the voyage that helped kick-start the anti-slavery movement
-
Trump pulls US from key climate pact, other bodiesSpeed Read The White House removed dozens of organizations from US participation
-
The Housemaid: an enjoyably ‘pulpy’ concoctionThe Week Recommends Formulaic psychological horror with Sydney Sweeney is ‘kind of a scream’
-
The Zorg: meticulously researched book is likely to ‘become a classic’
The Week Recommends Siddharth Kara’s harrowing account of the voyage that helped kick-start the anti-slavery movement
-
The Housemaid: an enjoyably ‘pulpy’ concoction
The Week Recommends Formulaic psychological horror with Sydney Sweeney is ‘kind of a scream’
-
William Nicholson: a ‘rich and varied’ exhibitionThe Week Recommends The wide-ranging show brings together portraits, illustrations, prints and posters, alongside ‘ravishing’ still lifes
-
Oh, Mary! – an ‘irreverent, counter-historical’ delightThe Week Recommends Mason Alexander Park ‘gives the funniest performance in town’ as former First Lady Mary Todd Lincoln
-
The ultimate films of 2025 by genreThe Week Recommends From comedies to thrillers, documentaries to animations, 2025 featured some unforgettable film moments
-
Into the Woods: a ‘hypnotic’ productionThe Week Recommends Jordan Fein’s revival of the much-loved Stephen Sondheim musical is ‘sharp, propulsive and often very funny’
-
The best food books of 2025The Week Recommends From mouthwatering recipes to insightful essays, these colourful books will both inspire and entertain
-
Art that made the news in 2025The Explainer From a short-lived Banksy mural to an Egyptian statue dating back three millennia
