Why Poland’s highest court has set it on a collision course with the EU
Constitutional tribunal rules that bloc’s laws are incompatible with national government
The highest court in Poland has ruled that some EU laws are incompatible with the nation’s constitution, prompting anger and threats of recriminations in Brussels.
In a move described by the BBC as a “major challenge to the EU’s legal framework”, the Constitutional Tribunal ruled the Polish constitution carried more weight than the EU treaties, meaning continent-wide legislation could not supersede national law.
The legal challenge was brought by Polish Prime Minister Mateusz Morawiecki and it is the first time in the history of the 27-strong bloc that a leader of a member state has questioned wholesale EU treaties in a constitutional court.
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
Unprecedented challenge
All members of the bloc agree to a treaty that dictates EU law has primacy over national law and that the final arbiter of EU law is the European Court of Justice in Luxembourg.
The agreement means that “where a conflict arises between an aspect of EU law and an aspect of law in an EU country (national law), EU law will prevail”, according to the bloc’s website.
The reason for this agreement is that “if this were not to be the case, EU countries could simply allow their national laws to take precedence over primary or secondary EU legislation”, meaning “the pursuit of EU policies would become unworkable”, the site added.
Sign up for Today's Best Articles in your inbox
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
However, the Polish verdict is a direct challenge to this. The government now insists that the justice system and the judiciary are the sole business of EU member nations and not the EU.
The tribunal said some provisions of EU treaties and EU court rulings clashed with Poland’s highest law, adding that EU institutions often “act beyond the scope of their competences”.
Public opinion
The ruling does not necessarily reflect the public mood about the EU. Surveys show that “more than 80% of Poles back EU membership”, said The Guardian.
But the ruling Law and Justice Party is currently “embroiled in a lengthening and increasingly acrimonious series of disputes” with the bloc, the paper reported. These range from disagreements over “judicial reforms” to battles over a national clampdown on issues from ”media freedoms to LGBT rights”.
While popular opinion in Poland still favours the EU, “many of those sitting on the tribunal are government loyalists, including the court’s president,” said The Telegraph. However, the ruling has drawn a “furious reaction from politicians in Brussels”.
The European Commission immediately said that it “will not hesitate to make use of its powers” to protect the primacy of EU law, accusing Morawiecki of putting the country on the “path to Polexit” and branding the constitutional tribunal “illegitimate”.
‘Polexit’
Some commentators have suggested that the ruling has moved Poland closer to exiting the EU, with The Times saying that it brings a Polexit “one step closer”. And senior diplomatic sources told the paper that the EU would tell Poland that it had to follow European law or leave.
A European ambassador said this tees up a simple scenario: “Poland will have to choose: accept the primacy of the EU under the treaty or leave.”
However, BBC Warsaw correspondent Adam Easton said that there is something else at play in Morawiecki’s decision to pick a fight with the bloc.
As Brussels has yet to approve a €57bn (£48bn) economic recovery plan outlined by the Polish government, he said that the ruling “could be hard ball tactics by Warsaw to get the commission to agree the much-needed funds”. But if that is the case, “it’s a risky ploy”, he added.
-
Is ChatGPT's new search engine OpenAI's Google 'killer'?
Talking Point There's a new AI-backed search engine in town. But can it stand up to Google's decades-long hold on internet searches?
By Theara Coleman, The Week US Published
-
Crossword: November 5, 2024
The Week's daily crossword
By The Week Staff Published
-
Sudoku hard: November 5, 2024
The Week's daily hard sudoku puzzle
By The Week Staff Published
-
Has the Taliban banned women from speaking?
Today's Big Question 'Rambling' message about 'bizarre' restriction joins series of recent decrees that amount to silencing of Afghanistan's women
By Harriet Marsden, The Week UK Published
-
Cuba's energy crisis
The Explainer Already beset by a host of issues, the island nation is struggling with nationwide blackouts
By Rebekah Evans, The Week UK Published
-
Putin's fixation with shamans
Under the Radar Secretive Russian leader, said to be fascinated with occult and pagan rituals, allegedly asked for blessing over nuclear weapons
By Harriet Marsden, The Week UK Published
-
Chimpanzees are dying of human diseases
Under the radar Great apes are vulnerable to human pathogens thanks to genetic similarity, increased contact and no immunity
By Harriet Marsden, The Week UK Published
-
Deaths of Jesse Baird and Luke Davies hang over Sydney's Mardi Gras
The Explainer Police officer, the former partner of TV presenter victim, charged with two counts of murder after turning himself in
By Austin Chen, The Week UK Published
-
Quiz of The Week: 24 February - 1 March
Puzzles and Quizzes Have you been paying attention to The Week's news?
By Sorcha Bradley, The Week UK Published
-
Will mounting discontent affect Iran election?
Today's Big Question Low turnout is expected in poll seen as crucial test for Tehran's leadership
By Sorcha Bradley, The Week UK Published
-
Sweden clears final NATO hurdle with Hungary vote
Speed Read Hungary's parliament overwhelmingly approved Sweden's accession to NATO
By Peter Weber, The Week US Published