Who is winning the war in Ukraine?

Volodymyr Zelenskyy has unveiled a heavily anticipated five-point "victory plan" which he claims could bring an end to the war by the end of next year.

An invitation to join Nato "sits front-and-centre" in Kyiv's blueprint for victory, said The Independent, which the Ukrainian president discussed with US, UK, France, Italy and Germany leaders before presenting it to the Ukrainian parliament on Wednesday.

Can Ukraine win the war?

Zelenskyy's five-point plan includes calls for specific weapons support from Western allies and a non-nuclear deterrence mechanism with the power to destroy Russia’s military, though "he said there is an additional secret addendum that he could not disclose", said Reuters.

Subscribe to The Week

Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.

SUBSCRIBE & SAVE

Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

Sign up

As Ukraine battles to slow the advance of Russia further into its territory, the outcome of the war looks increasingly likely to be decided by two key factors: supply of soldiers and maintaining international support.

Earlier this year, Zelenskyy lowered the age of military conscription in Ukraine to 25 in an attempt to boost troop numbers. But conscription remains a touchy topic in Ukraine, and officials have had to tread lightly amid dwindling enthusiasm for military service. "We don't only have a military crisis – we have a political one," one of the officers speaking to Politico warned.

Earlier this week, Al Jazeera reported that "feared patrols" are hunting for potential conscripts, as officials searching for recruits "stalk nightclubs, concerts and subway stations". There are accusations that some are employing "dubious measures", including that they "round people up randomly".

Ukraine's "inherent weakness is that it depends on others for funding and arms", wrote the BBC's international editor, Jeremy Bowen. On the other hand Russia – in addition to an advantage in raw manpower – "makes most of its own weapons" and is "buying drones from Iran and ammunition from North Korea" with no limitations on how they are used.

For now, Russia retains an "advantage in manpower, equipment and ammunition", said Foreign Affairs. This advantage has "not proved decisive, or led to operationally significant breakthroughs", but Russian forces have steadily gained 750 square miles of territory since October 2023, and with the pace of that advance now accelerating, Ukraine's position looks "increasingly precarious along parts of the front".

This "mismatch" between Moscow and Kyiv remains a "key thread" of Zelenskyy's ongoing call for more Western help, said the BBC's Europe correspondent, Nick Beake.

If the "worst-case scenario" for Ukraine materialises, said CNN, namely if the US stopped providing aid, Europe did not step up its assistance and Ukraine was not able to access the $50 billion or so in frozen Russian assets promised to it by the G7, then Russia would "likely start to make much bigger gains" which could force Kyiv to the negotiating table.

What about Ukraine's incursion into Russia?

Russia's Kursk region, on the border with Ukraine, has been engulfed in conflict for over two months. Kyiv's surprise incursion into the southern region was "designed partly to pressure Russian generals to scramble forces from other parts of the eastern front in Ukraine", said Reuters. The continued presence of Ukrainian forces on Russian soil has caused considerable embarrassment to the Kremlin and anger among the local population.

In August, Kyiv claimed it had controlled over 1,250 square kilometres of Russia's territory, including 92 settlements, but a spokesperson for Russia’s counteroffensive in the Kursk region claimed this week that about 50% of the territory captured by Ukraine during the incursion had been retaken.

Also, it "remains unclear how Ukraine's leaders intend to translate this tactical success into strategic or political gains" with the incursion offering "opportunities," but also carrying "considerable risks and costs".

What does victory look like for each side?

Before Russia launched its invasion in February 2022, Putin outlined the objectives of what he called a "special military operation". His goal, he claimed, was to "denazify" and "demilitarise" Ukraine, and to defend Donetsk and Luhansk, the two eastern Ukrainian territories occupied by Russian proxy forces since 2014.

Another objective, although never explicitly stated, was to topple the Ukrainian government and remove the country's president, Zelenskyy. "The enemy has designated me as target number one; my family is target number two," said Zelenskyy shortly after the invasion. Russian troops made two attempts to storm the presidential compound.

Russia shifted its objectives, however, about a month into the invasion, after Russian forces were forced to retreat from Kyiv and Chernihiv. According to the Kremlin, its main goal became the "liberation of the Donbas", including the regions of Kherson and Zaporizhzhia – but Moscow has made little progress in achieving this aim.

Ukraine's main objective remains the liberation of its occupied territories. That includes not just those held by Russia since the February 2022 invasion, but a return to its internationally recognised borders, including Crimea.

How many Russian and Ukrainian troops have died in the conflict?

True casualty figures are "notoriously difficult to pin down", said Newsweek, and "experts caution that both sides likely inflate the other's reported losses". But in September, The Wall Street Journal reported that about one million Ukrainians and Russians have been killed or wounded since the war began. The report also said that, in the first half of 2024, three times as many people died in Ukraine as were born.

In May, an investigation by the BBC's Russian unit was able to identify 52,155 named Russian military personnel who have died in the conflict so far. But statistical data on excess deaths suggested that the true figure could be more than 100,000.

In September, it said that more than 70,000 people fighting in Russia’s military have now died in Ukraine, and for the first time, volunteers – civilians who joined the armed forces after the start of the war – "now make up the highest number of people killed on the battlefield" since the invasion began in 2022.

As for Ukraine, it is "extremely unusual" for the country's media to report on casualty figures, reported The Times. Zelenskyy said in February that 31,000 Ukrainian soldiers had died since Russia invaded in February 2022, but US officials claimed last August that the Ukrainian death toll was more than twice that figure.