Is time up for TikTok in the US?

Texas has joined Maryland, South Dakota, South Carolina and Nebraska and the US military in banning the use of TikTok on government-issued devices.

In just five years, the Chinese-owned video app has amassed more than one billion active users across more than 150 countries. But while TikTok has become a major news source for millennials and Gen Z adults alike, security concerns have also increased.

In a letter ordering all Texas state agencies to ditch TikTok, Governor Greg Abbott said the app “harvests vast amounts of data from its users’ devices” and “offers this trove of potentially sensitive information to the Chinese government”.

Subscribe to The Week

Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.

SUBSCRIBE & SAVE

Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

Sign up

Scrutiny from lawmakers

Nebraska outlawed TikTok from government devices in August 2020, a year after the US military did so. And last Wednesday Texas became the fourth state in a week to implement similar bans, amid a Republican-led push for a TikTok crackdown.

Indiana has gone a step further, suing TikTok for alleged security and safety violations. Indian’s Attorney General Todd Rokita has accused ByteDance, the app’s parent company, of “exposing children to mature content and not disclosing that China could access users’ data”, reported NBC News.

A pair of lawsuits filed last week by Rokita seek emergency injunctive relief and civil penalties from the app.

TikTok is facing “mounting scrutiny from US lawmakers over its data practices”, said the FT, but these security concerns are not new. During his term as president, Donald Trump threatened to ban the app.

In June, the Joe Biden administration ordered a review of foreign-owned apps, a move widely viewed as a warning to the Chinese government.

TikTok has expressed “disappointment” at the latest state bans. In a statement, the company said the crackdowns had been “largely fuelled by misinformation”.

TikTok is on “a path in our negotiations with the US government to fully satisfy all reasonable US national security concerns”, the statement added.

Congress’s next Big Tech target

TikTok appears to be “Congress’s next Big Tech target”, said Vox reporter Sara Morrison. Although the app “has tried to distance itself from its Chinese parent company”, she wrote, “those claims have been undermined by recent reports that say ByteDance has a great deal of control over TikTok and its direction”.

In an article for The Washington Post last month, two Republican senators – Florida’s Marco Rubio and Wisconsin’s Mike Gallagher – justified their decision to introduce legislation that would ban TikTok and other Chinese social media companies from operating in the US.

TikTok and “by extension” the Chinese Communist Party have “the ability to survey every keystroke teenagers enter on their phones”, the senators wrote. Unless the app and its algorithm can be separated from Beijing, its use in the US “will continue to jeopardise our country’s safety and pave the way for a Chinese-influenced tech landscape here”, they argued.

But while “an all-out ban on TikTok in the US is possible”, it feels unlikely, said Forbes. “A lot of water would have to go under the bridge for it to happen anytime soon.”

Aside from some states banning the app on government phones, the federal government has done “little thus far to regulate TikTok”, the site pointed out, “let alone ban it for all US users”.