Jewish communities are wary of Trump's push to punish antisemitism
While the White House expands its effort to criminalize actions it deems harmful to Jewish Americans, not everyone in those communities is on board


President Donald Trump has long portrayed himself as a steadfast friend and fierce protector of Jewish people the world over. Jewish Americans, however, have been mostly unconvinced, voting overwhelmingly for Democrat Kamala Harris in 2024, keeping with decades of precedent for liberal candidates. Nevertheless, just days into his second term, Trump signed an executive order to "combat antisemitism," focusing largely on the campus-roiling protests against Israel's war on the Gaza Strip.
Since then, the Trump administration has targeted several international students for deportation, ostensibly over their roles in the recent protests. At the same time, allegations of permitting antisemitism to flourish on campus have been the purported basis for the White House's push to defund Ivy League schools like Columbia and Brown University. But as the White House touts its efforts, a growing number of Jewish Americans have begun speaking out about what they claim is the exploitation of their identities for the president's personal agenda.
'Uncomfortable' spotlight
The Trump administration has been "using 'antisemitism' as a pretext to advance a radical agenda," said Yair Rosenberg at The Atlantic. That agenda has "nothing to do with Jews at all" and is one that "most American Jews do not support." In the case of "detentions and deportations," for instance, while a "handful of high-profile cases" purport to be predicated on the subject's alleged antisemitic actions, "most of them do not." In so much as there have been instances of actual antisemitism on campuses, Trump has not "surgically targeted these failings at America's universities for rectification," said Rosenberg. Instead, he has "exploited them to justify the institutions' decimation."
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.

Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
To the extent that Trump's crackdowns have "so far targeted critics of Israel," some Jewish Americans nevertheless contend that his administration's actions "uncomfortably echo previous eras of bigoted nationalism that gave way to overt antisemitism," said The New York Times. The result, whether intended or not, is a "spotlight on Jews that makes many uncomfortable."
Some Jewish communal groups that have previously backed the Trump administration are beginning to speak out about their discomfort with the White House's tactics claiming to help protect Jews. After initially lauding Trump for the detention of Columbia University student and Gaza war protester Mahmoud Khalil, Anti-Defamation League CEO Jonathan Greenblatt made "something of a shift" by gently critiquing the White House in the days that followed, said Jewish Insider. Protecting Jewish students "shouldn't require us to shred the norms that we use to protect other people," said Greenblatt in an interview with the publication.
Trump may have "couched" his "aggressive moves" against universities like Columbia and Princeton as a "means of protecting Jewish students," said the Forward. At the same time, however, he has shuttered the Department of Education, which is the governmental body with the "most responsibility for investigating antisemitism."
'Weaponizing' real pain
There is a "disdain for the exploitation of real concerns about antisemitism" on campuses when it's used to "fuel a broader crackdown on liberal education," said Jewish Studies Professor Joel Swanson at Slate. Students see a "pretext of fighting antisemitism" being used to "destroy the foundations of the liberal arts education." This, in turn, has a chilling effect on those wanting to speak out over "legitimate concerns about antisemitism on campus."
Trump is "weaponizing the real pain American Jews face," said Rep. Jerry Nadler (D-N.Y.), and he is using that pain as a tool in his "desire to wield control over the truth-seeking academic institutions that stand as a bulwark against authoritarianism." Search for a moment in history where Jews have "benefited from a mix of rampant nationalism and repression," said Matt Bai at The Washington Post, in a critique of Greenblatt's previous support for the Trump administration published two days before the Jewish Insider interview: "You'll be looking awhile."
Sign up for Today's Best Articles in your inbox
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
Rafi Schwartz has worked as a politics writer at The Week since 2022, where he covers elections, Congress and the White House. He was previously a contributing writer with Mic focusing largely on politics, a senior writer with Splinter News, a staff writer for Fusion's news lab, and the managing editor of Heeb Magazine, a Jewish life and culture publication. Rafi's work has appeared in Rolling Stone, GOOD and The Forward, among others.
-
India strikes Pakistan as tensions mount in Kashmir
speed read Pakistan's Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif called it an 'act of war'
-
Laurence Leamer's 6 favorite books that took courage to write
Feature The author recommends works by George Orwell, Truman Capote and more
-
Today's political cartoons - May 7, 2025
Cartoons Wednesday's cartoons - film industry tariffs, self-deportation, and more
-
Another messaging app used by the White House is in hot water
The Explainer TeleMessage was seen being used by former National Security Adviser Mike Waltz
-
How does the Alien Enemies Act work?
Feature President Trump is using a long-dormant law to deport Venezuelans. How does it work?
-
Baby bonus: Can Trump boost the birth rate?
Feature The Trump administration is encouraging Americans to have more babies while also cutting funding for maternal and postpartum care
-
Hollywood confounded by Trump's film tariff idea
speed read President Trump proposed a '100% tariff' on movies 'produced in foreign lands'
-
Trump offers migrants $1,000 to 'self-deport'
speed read The Department of Homeland Security says undocumented immigrants can leave the US in a more 'dignified way'
-
Deportations ensnare migrant families, U.S. citizens
Feature Trump's deportation crackdown is sweeping up more than just immigrants as ICE targets citizens, judges and nursing mothers
-
Trump shrugs off warnings over trade war costs
Feature Trump's tariffs are spiraling the U.S. toward an economic crisis as shipments slow down—and China doesn't plan to back down
-
Harvard stares down Trump's tax threat as other schools take note
IN THE SPOTLIGHT Higher ed is on high alert as the nation's premier university prepares to take on the fight of its life