Is Facebook always listening to me?

Facebook has admitted that it paid contractors to listen to voice recordings of users’ private conversations.

The social media giant confirmed that it had been “transcribing users’ audio” after company insiders told Bloomberg that people were hired to analyse conversations on the firm’s Messenger service.

The aim was to check the accuracy of speech-to-text artificial intelligence (AI) systems, the news site says.

Subscribe to The Week

Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.

SUBSCRIBE & SAVE

Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.

Sign up

Facebook told Bloomberg that it has now stopped transcribing user recordings after rival tech firms, including Apple, Google and Amazon, came under fire for a similar practice.

“Much like Apple and Google, we paused human review of audio more than a week ago,” a Facebook spokesperson said.

Although “human oversight” of automated systems is commonplace in the tech industry, The Guardian says that examining user conversations from chat apps and voice-activated speakers poses “a significantly higher level of concern over privacy”.

How - and why - Facebook records your voice

As reported by The Daily Telegraph, audio recordings were analysed courtesy of the “voice chat transcription option” in Facebook’s Messenger app. The option lets users record a brief audio clip, which is then sent to a recipient and transcribed into text through AI.

Facebook’s privacy policy doesn’t explicitly say that these recordings would be evaluated by a human moderator, but it does state that “content, communications and other information you provide” may be shared with “vendors and service providers who support our business”, the paper adds.

Facebook claims that it used human moderators to help improve the accuracy of its products, which include the AI system that transcribes audio messages into text on the Messenger app, the Financial Times notes.

The firm also insists that the identity of users was anonymised before their voice recordings were passed on to the contractors, the FT says.��

What did the contractors hear?

Sources familiar with the practice told Bloomberg that the contractors were not told how the audio files were obtained or where they were recorded. The moderators were simply asked to listen to the recordings and transcribe them.

The company insiders say the moderators could listen to “Facebook users’ conversations”, some of which contained “vulgar content”, the news site reports. The contractors, however, were unaware as to why Facebook needed the recordings transcribed.

Contractors working for other firms appear to have been exposed to more extreme content.

In an interview with Vice, one moderator, working for the Microsoft-owned video calling service Skype, said that they could hear conversations that could “clearly be described as phone sex”, as well as “people entering full addresses” or asking the Cortana AI system to “provide search returns on pornography queries.

“While I don’t know exactly what one could do with this information, it seems odd to me that it isn’t being handled in a more controlled environment,” the contractor said.

So is Facebook always listening to me?

Judging by comments made to Bloomberg, it would appear that Facebook does not listen to every user at all times - especially now the firm states that it no longer examines voice recordings.

But Jake Moore, a cybersecurity specialist at ESET, told Forbes that Facebook “already admits to scanning Messenger content such as text, images and links for many reasons so transcribing audio or video content is really just an add on to what they are already doing.

“Micro targeted advertising is their multimillion-dollar business so naturally there may be data within this audio which will add to people’s profile,” he said. “However, where this becomes a privacy matter or even grey area is, people wrongly tend to assume that this content is private from all eyes and ears.”