The Archers trial: Essential listening or a step too far?
Domestic abuse storyline keeps many listeners 'riveted', but others long for the Ambridge of old
WARNING: This story contains spoilers
Millions of listeners tuned into the BBC Radio 4 drama The Archers last night to hear the gripping conclusion to the fictional trial of Helen Titchener for the attempted murder of her abusive husband Rob – but has the show lost its way?
Following a week of Archers episodes focusing on the trial, the special hour-long instalment concluded the high-profile domestic abuse plot and delivered a verdict on the incident in which Helen was accused of stabbing Rob. It featured a star cast of jurors, including Nigel Havers, Dame Eileen Atkins and Catherine Tate, who considered Helen's fate at Borchester Crown Court.
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
After a period of nerve-wracking deliberations, in which Havers's character seemed determined to find Helen guilty, Dame Eileen's character managed to convince enough fellow jury members that there was reasonable doubt. The majority verdict was not guilty of both counts of attempted murder and wounding with intent.
"The nation breathed a collective sigh of relief after the fate of Helen Titchener was finally revealed," says Siobhan Fenton in The Independent. She says the drama has become "essential listening" after keeping audiences hooked for weeks with its tense domestic abuse plotline.
The outcome also prompted thousands of responses on social media, causing the show to trend on Twitter for hours after the episode aired. Members of the public, celebrities and even some politicians tweeted their comments.
Like many listeners, Allison Pearson in the Daily Telegraph, says that she was left shaken by the story. We had "knots in our guts, tears in our eyes, dread in our hearts, gin in our trembling hands".
But this new kind of Archers – "EastEnders with hay bales and marital rape" – is not to everyone's taste, notes Pearson. It has "alternately riveted and angered listeners", many of whom preferred it when Ambridge was rocked by scandals about undermarked marrows at the village fete.
Thousands have switched off since the abuse plotline began, adds Pearson, even if "few could resist the gravitational pull" of this episode.
I fear "it's curtains" for The Archers as we know it if it keeps trying to chase ratings like this, says Kate Chisholm in The Spectator. The domestic-abuse storyline was gripping to begin with, she says, but in reality "abuse is too raw, too monotonously awful, too dull" for the writers, who "turned the storyline into cheap melodrama".
In fact the whole soap has been "well and truly done over, and every halfway believable character cast off, every spot of light relief subsumed into the desperate desire to crank up the ratings", says Chisholm.
We know Ambridge is a soap whose happenings are "mere whispers in the mind", argues the commentator. She adds: "Just make it true to life."
Sign up for Today's Best Articles in your inbox
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
-
The Count of Monte Cristo review: 'indecently spectacular' adaptation
The Week Recommends Dumas's classic 19th-century novel is once again given new life in this 'fast-moving' film
By The Week UK Published
-
Death of England: Closing Time review – 'bold, brash reflection on racism'
The Week Recommends The final part of this trilogy deftly explores rising political tensions across the country
By The Week UK Published
-
Sing Sing review: prison drama bursts with 'charm, energy and optimism'
The Week Recommends Colman Domingo plays a real-life prisoner in a performance likely to be an Oscars shoo-in
By The Week UK Published
-
Kaos review: comic retelling of Greek mythology starring Jeff Goldblum
The Week Recommends The new series captures audiences as it 'never takes itself too seriously'
By The Week UK Published
-
Blink Twice review: a 'stylish and savage' black comedy thriller
The Week Recommends Channing Tatum and Naomi Ackie stun in this film on the hedonistic rich directed by Zoë Kravitz
By The Week UK Published
-
Shifters review: 'beautiful' new romantic comedy offers 'bittersweet tenderness'
The Week Recommends The 'inventive, emotionally astute writing' leaves audiences gripped throughout
By The Week UK Published
-
How to do F1: British Grand Prix 2025
The Week Recommends One of the biggest events of the motorsports calendar is back and better than ever
By Rebekah Evans, The Week UK Published
-
Twisters review: 'warm-blooded' film explores dangerous weather
The Week Recommends The film, focusing on 'tornado wranglers', stars Daisy Edgar-Jones and Glen Powell
By The Week UK Published